Court Shifts Uninsured Workers' Comp Liability to State Fund

A South Carolina appeals court reversed a commission ruling that had denied a general contractor's request to transfer benefit liability.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Employment

Court Shifts Uninsured Workers' Comp Liability to State Fund

The South Carolina Court of Appeals reversed the Workers' Compensation Commission's denial of a liability transfer to the Uninsured Employers' Fund. A general contractor had paid statutory maximum benefits to an injured truck driver employed by a subcontractor whose workers' compensation policy had lapsed.

Why it matters

The ruling clarifies that a contractor seeking transfer under South Carolina Code §42-1-415 is not required to submit proof of a subcontractor's coverage on the exact day a claim is filed. It affects how general contractors in South Carolina can recover benefit costs when subcontractors fail to maintain required insurance.

The record shows 500 weeks of statutory maximum benefits paid by the contractor and a certificate submitted 34 days after the claim was filed, but the total dollar cost and remaining obligations are not stated. The Fund's future payment schedule has not been reported.

The players

Workers' Compensation Commission

South Carolina's state body that adjudicates workers' compensation claims and had denied the liability transfer before the appellate reversal.

Uninsured Employers' Fund

A South Carolina fund that assumes workers' compensation liability when an employer lacks valid coverage, and to which liability was shifted by the court.

The details

The contractor had obtained an ACORD certificate of insurance from the subcontractor, but the subcontractor's policy had lapsed for nonpayment before a 2011 vehicle accident injured a truck driver. The commission denied the transfer, finding the certificate insufficient and the timing requirements unmet, and the appeals court reversed that decision.

Timeline

  1. 2011: A truck driver employed by the subcontractor was injured in a work-related vehicle accident.

  2. 34 days after the claim was filed: The contractor submitted the ACORD certificate to the Commission.

  3. November 15, 2026: The Court of Appeals issued its opinion reversing the Commission.

Legal Context

The decision interprets South Carolina Code §42-1-415 to require contractors to submit subcontractor coverage proof without a same-day deadline, reversing a stricter reading applied by the Commission. Courts in the state have now clarified how this transfer provision applies to lapsed subcontractor policies.

General contractors who rely on subcontractor insurance certificates may now have a clearer path to recover benefit costs if a subcontractor's policy lapses. Workers injured on subcontracted jobs may see their benefits paid through the Uninsured Employers' Fund rather than delayed in dispute.

The takeaway

Businesses that hire subcontractors should verify active workers' compensation coverage directly rather than relying on a certificate alone. Timely documentation can determine whether liability stays with the contractor or shifts to the state fund.

Further reading

Explore more on employment law and related workplace coverage across South Carolina.

Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.