Supreme Court Limits Inmate Sexual Assault Case to Four

The South Carolina Supreme Court reversed statewide class certification and sent the case back for trial on four named plaintiffs' individual claims.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a neoclassical state building facade under a pale sky, with a single limp flag at its peak in navy, cream, and oxblood tones.
The South Carolina Supreme Court on Monday reversed statewide class certification in inmate sexual assault suits, sending the case to trial only on four named plaintiffs' individual claims. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust state agencies to protect people in their custody?

The South Carolina Supreme Court reversed a trial court's certification of statewide class actions brought by inmates alleging sexual assault. The case was remanded to Dorchester County Circuit Court for discovery and trial solely on the individual claims of four named plaintiffs.

Why it matters

The ruling sets a stricter predominance standard under Rule 23 of the South Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure and bars immediate appeals of class certification orders to the Court of Appeals. It affects how inmates in state custody can pursue claims against the Department of Corrections and the Department of Juvenile Justice in South Carolina.

The case has been remanded to Dorchester County Circuit Court for discovery and trial on the individual claims of four named plaintiffs. No trial date or merits ruling has been reported.

The players

South Carolina Department of Corrections

The state agency that operates South Carolina's adult prisons and was named as a defendant in the inmates' proposed class actions.

South Carolina Department of Juvenile Justice

The state agency responsible for youth in state custody, also named as a defendant in the proposed inmate classes.

The details

The proposed classes included inmates in the custody of the South Carolina Department of Corrections and the South Carolina Department of Juvenile Justice, who alleged the agencies negligently failed to implement adequate policies, staffing and procedures to prevent sexual assaults. The court held each plaintiff's claim would require separate factual findings, and overruled prior precedent suggesting Rule 23 permits broader certification than its federal counterpart.

Timeline

  1. November 15, 2026: South Carolina Supreme Court publishes ruling reversing statewide inmate class certification.

Legal Context

The decision brings South Carolina's class action standard in line with the federal predominance requirement and overrules precedent that had allowed broader certification. It also forecloses immediate appellate review of certification orders, a procedural limit that shapes how similar mass claims by incarcerated people can proceed.

Incarcerated people in South Carolina state prisons and juvenile facilities must now pursue sexual assault claims individually rather than as statewide classes. Families and advocates following these cases should expect individualized discovery and trial rather than a single consolidated proceeding.

The takeaway

Class action limits like this one mean individual claims carry more weight in state litigation involving incarcerated people. Readers following similar cases should track the individual rulings that will now define outcomes.

Further reading

Explore more on Criminal Justice coverage across South Carolina.

Live Poll

Do you trust state agencies to protect people in their custody?