Fourth Circuit Upholds Dismissal of South Carolina OSHA Challenge
A federal appeals court affirmed dismissal of South Carolina's facial challenge to a 2016 OSHA rule on state safety plan penalties.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Law

The Fourth Circuit affirmed a district court ruling dismissing South Carolina's claims against a 2016 OSHA rule requiring state workplace safety plans to keep civil penalties at least as high as federal penalties. The court held the state's claim accrued when OSHA published the interim final rule, placing the challenge outside the Administrative Procedure Act's six-year limitations period.
Why it matters
The ruling limits when states can challenge federal workplace safety rules on their face, affecting how other state-run safety plans may respond to federal oversight. South Carolina may still raise its arguments as a defense if OSHA later initiates enforcement to revoke approval of its plan.
The 2016 interim final rule was published in 2016, and South Carolina filed its facial challenge in 2023, outside the six-year Administrative Procedure Act window the court applied. OSHA issued a formal noncompliance finding against South Carolina in 2022, but no enforcement proceeding had begun as of the ruling.
The players
U.S. Department of Labor
The U.S. Department of Labor oversees the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, which sets and enforces federal workplace safety standards and approves state-run safety plans.
South Carolina
South Carolina is a state that operates its own occupational safety plan under federal OSHA approval and brought the challenge against the 2016 rule.
The details
The court found the cause of action accrued when OSHA published the rule, not when the state was later found noncompliant. The district court had dismissed the state's claims, and the Fourth Circuit's nine-page opinion affirmed that dismissal.
Timeline
2016: OSHA publishes the interim final rule on state safety plan penalties.
2022: OSHA issues a formal noncompliance finding against South Carolina.
2023: South Carolina files its facial challenge to the 2016 rule.
Political Context
South Carolina's challenge reflects a broader dispute over how much latitude states retain under federally approved workplace safety plans. The court's timing holding means states must bring facial challenges to federal rules within six years of publication, regardless of when enforcement begins.
For South Carolina employers and workers, the ruling leaves the state's current safety plan in place for now. A future OSHA enforcement action could bring changes to how the state sets its civil penalties, which would affect businesses operating under state oversight.
The takeaway
Facial challenges to federal rules face strict timing limits, so states and businesses should track when rules are published, not just when they are enforced. Monitoring OSHA's enforcement activity is the next signal for how this ruling plays out in practice.
Further reading
Explore more on South Carolina Law for related court rulings and legal developments.
Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.









