Appeals Court Upholds $1 Million Verdict for Mold Tenants

A South Carolina appellate court affirmed a jury award to tenants who alleged mold-related habitability violations at a Mount Pleasant apartment complex.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Apartments

Appeals Court Upholds $1 Million Verdict for Mold Tenants

Live Poll

Do you trust landlords to keep rental apartments free of mold and safe?

The South Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed a $1 million jury verdict for tenants who alleged mold-related habitability violations at a Mount Pleasant apartment property. The court also affirmed a discovery sanctions order against the landlord defendants.

Why it matters

The ruling upholds a significant civil award under the South Carolina Residential Landlord Tenant Act and reinforces tenants' ability to pursue negligence claims over habitability conditions. It also signals that courts may sanction landlords for delayed discovery compliance.

The appellate court affirmed a $1 million jury verdict in a 2022 trial, after the circuit court denied post-trial motions for judgment notwithstanding the verdict or a new trial. The extraction does not state whether further appeal is planned.

The players

South Carolina Court of Appeals

The state's intermediate appellate court, which reviews rulings from the circuit courts and is the body that affirmed the verdict in this case.

The details

Tenants who moved into the apartment complex in May 2017 were relocated after their first unit flooded and later found black mold in another unit, moving out in September 2017. They sued for negligence, alleging the mold caused physical symptoms and that management failed to adequately remediate it despite complaints. Before trial, the defendants produced notebooks containing discoverable information despite an earlier order compelling discovery, and the circuit court awarded attorney's fees as a sanction rather than striking the defendants' pleadings.

Timeline

  1. May 2017: Tenants moved into the apartment complex.

  2. September 2017: Tenants moved out after discovering mold.

  3. 2022: Jury trial held and verdict returned for the tenants.

  4. November 15, 2026: Court of Appeals decision published.

Legal Context

The affirmed award applies the South Carolina Residential Landlord Tenant Act's habitability obligations to a mold dispute, and the appellate affirmance reinforces how state courts enforce landlord duties to repair. The decision shows that discovery sanctions, including attorney's fees, can accompany a habitability verdict.

Renters in South Carolina may find that habitability complaints such as mold and flooding can lead to lasting legal remedies when landlords fail to repair. The ruling underscores that documenting complaints and relocation history can matter in a later negligence claim.

The takeaway

Tenants facing persistent mold or flooding should keep written records of complaints, repair requests and any relocations, since such documentation supports habitability claims. Landlords are reminded that discovery obligations are enforceable and can carry monetary sanctions.

Further reading

Explore more on Apartments to see how habitability rules shape rental living in South Carolina.

Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.

Live Poll

Do you trust landlords to keep rental apartments free of mold and safe?