Court Upholds Foreclosure Rulings in South Carolina Case

Appeals court finds earlier Rule 40(j) removals did not bar Deutsche Bank's 2019 renewed foreclosure action against the borrowers.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Debt Relief

A weathered stone civic building with a columned portico, framed by live oaks and an empty walkway under soft afternoon light.
South Carolina's appeals court upheld summary judgment for Deutsche Bank and Nationstar Mortgage, ruling that earlier Rule 40(j) removals did not bar a 2019 renewed foreclosure action. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The South Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment for Deutsche Bank and Nationstar Mortgage in a foreclosure dispute. The court held that three Rule 40(j) removal orders were not adjudications on the merits, so a 2019 renewed foreclosure action was not barred.

Why it matters

The ruling clarifies that repeated administrative removal of a foreclosure case from the active roster does not automatically operate like a final dismissal. Borrowers facing renewed foreclosure filings may find that earlier removals do not shield them from new actions.

The mortgage was originated in 2007 at $1.5 million and the first foreclosure action was filed in 2009, then stricken from the active roster three times under Rule 40(j). The stub does not state whether the borrowers plan to pursue further appellate review.

The players

Deutsche Bank

Deutsche Bank is a major global investment bank and financial services firm headquartered in Frankfurt, Germany.

Nationstar Mortgage

Nationstar Mortgage is a nonbank mortgage servicer and originator, now operating as Mr. Cooper, that services residential home loans across the United States.

The details

The court found that the earlier foreclosure was stricken through court orders rather than unilateral dismissals, and that Rule 40(j) contains no provision making a later removal an adjudication on the merits. The borrowers' malicious prosecution, negligent misrepresentation and unfair trade practices claims were also rejected.

Timeline

  1. 2007: The mortgage was originated.

  2. 2009: The first foreclosure action was filed.

  3. 2016: The third Rule 40(j) removal order was issued and the case was not restored.

  4. 2019: Deutsche Bank filed a new foreclosure action.

  5. November 9, 2026: The Court of Appeals decision was published.

Market Dynamics

The decision interprets South Carolina Rule 40(j), which allows cases to be removed from the active roster, and holds that such removals do not bar a later action on the same mortgage. The ruling sets a clearer rule for lenders and borrowers navigating repeated foreclosure filings in the state.

Homeowners facing foreclosure in South Carolina may see renewed filings proceed even after earlier cases were removed from the active roster. Borrowers should expect that defenses must be raised within the ongoing foreclosure action rather than relying on prior removals.

The takeaway

Repeated administrative removals of a foreclosure case do not necessarily end a lender's right to refile. Homeowners facing renewed foreclosure should review the full procedural history of their case with a qualified attorney.

Further reading

For more on how foreclosure and loan relief work, explore Debt Relief coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.