South Carolina Supreme Court Overrules Logan Instructions

The court ruled that additional circumstantial evidence instructions beyond the reasonable doubt standard should no longer be given to juries in the state.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain stone courthouse facade with columns under a pale sky, in deep red and cream.
The South Carolina Supreme Court overruled State v. Logan, ending the use of additional circumstantial-evidence jury instructions beyond the reasonable doubt standard. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The South Carolina Supreme Court overruled State v. Logan to the extent it required or authorized additional circumstantial evidence jury instructions. The court also affirmed the denial of post-conviction relief for Andre T. Heatley Jr., who was convicted of murdering and robbing Deanndra Roach.

Why it matters

The decision resolves uncertainty created by the Grippon, Cherry, and Logan line of cases about which circumstantial evidence instruction trial courts and attorneys should use. Juries in future South Carolina criminal cases will evaluate direct and circumstantial evidence under the same reasonable doubt standard.

The court affirmed the denial of post-conviction relief for Andre T. Heatley Jr., whose convictions for murder and robbery of Deanndra Roach stand. Whether further appeals will follow was not addressed in the ruling.

The players

South Carolina Supreme Court

The state's highest court, which issues binding rulings on South Carolina law and criminal procedure.

The details

Heatley's case relied heavily on circumstantial evidence, including text messages, cell phone location data, ATM surveillance tied to the victim's credit card, and forensic evidence linking a bullet to a gun found in his car. Heatley argued his trial attorney was ineffective for not requesting the instruction authorized by Logan, but the court concluded Logan improperly added requirements beyond the constitutional reasonable doubt standard.

Timeline

  1. November 15, 2026: South Carolina Supreme Court decision published and reported by Lawyers Weekly.

Legal Context

The ruling overrules State v. Logan in part, ending a line of South Carolina cases that had required additional circumstantial evidence instructions beyond the Grippon standard. The court relied on the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Holland v. United States to conclude that the constitutional reasonable doubt standard is sufficient.

Defendants in South Carolina criminal trials will no longer receive the additional circumstantial evidence instruction, so juries will apply the standard reasonable doubt test to both direct and circumstantial evidence. Prosecutors and defense attorneys in the state will need to adjust how they argue circumstantial cases under the new framework.

The takeaway

Circumstantial evidence now carries the same reasonable doubt standard as direct evidence in South Carolina courtrooms. Readers following criminal cases in the state should expect juries to be instructed under this unified framework going forward.

Further reading

Explore more coverage of Criminal Justice rulings and procedures across South Carolina.

Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.