Court Upholds Insurer's Denial of $250,000 Wire Fraud Claim

South Carolina's appeals court affirmed summary judgment for Chubb Limited against a law firm that lost funds in a phishing scheme.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Financial Crime

Court Upholds Insurer's Denial of $250,000 Wire Fraud Claim

The South Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment for Chubb Limited after the insurer denied a law firm's claim for a $250,000 wire transfer sent to a Hong Kong account following a fraudulent email. The court ruled that the policy's false pretense exclusion applied, and that the forgery endorsement did not cover the loss.

Why it matters

The ruling clarifies that a transfer made voluntarily after deception may fall outside commercial crime coverage, even when the transfer was induced by a phishing scheme. Businesses that rely on Money and Securities or Forgery endorsements for social-engineering losses may need to review how those exclusions apply to their own policies.

The Court of Appeals has affirmed summary judgment in favor of Chubb Limited, concluding the coverage dispute at the appellate level. The stub does not indicate any further appeal or remaining proceedings.

The players

Chubb Limited

Chubb Limited is a Swiss-domiciled multinational insurance company that underwrites commercial and personal property and casualty coverage worldwide.

The details

A law firm bookkeeper wired $250,000 to a Hong Kong account after receiving an email that appeared to come from the firm's attorney, whose account had been compromised. The court held that the transfer was voluntary and induced by deception, and that the policy's false pretense exclusion applied to the Money and Securities endorsement.

Timeline

  1. The South Carolina Court of Appeals decision was published online on November 15, 2026.

Legal Context

The decision reflects a broader pattern in which courts enforce false pretense exclusions in commercial crime policies against business email compromise claims. Insurers and policyholders in South Carolina now have appellate guidance on how voluntariness is assessed under these endorsements.

Businesses that handle client funds may need to review whether their commercial crime policies cover social-engineering losses and whether verification procedures for payment requests are adequate. Firms should confirm how false pretense and voluntary-parting language apply to their own coverage.

The takeaway

Verifying payment instructions by phone before wiring funds can help prevent losses that insurance may not cover. Reviewing the exclusions in your commercial crime policy now is far easier than doing so after a fraudulent transfer.

Further reading

For more on related fraud cases, see Financial Crime coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.