South Carolina Court Upholds $12.49M Amazon Tax Bill
The state Supreme Court affirmed a sales tax assessment covering unpaid taxes from early 2016 on third-party marketplace sales.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Retail

Live Poll
Should online marketplaces like Amazon be required to collect sales tax on third-party sales?
The South Carolina Supreme Court affirmed a $12.49 million sales tax assessment against Amazon Services, LLC, covering unpaid sales taxes, penalties, and interest from the first three months of 2016. The court also rejected Amazon's argument that it was not the statutory seller of third-party goods.
Why it matters
The ruling holds that a marketplace operator can be treated as a seller under state sales tax law based on how deeply it controls transactions. It applied the statute as written in 2016, before South Carolina's 2019 marketplace facilitator law took effect.
The court affirmed a $12.49 million assessment covering unpaid taxes, penalties, and interest on sales from January through March 2016. The source does not say whether Amazon will pursue further appeal or how the figure compares with other marketplace assessments.
The players
Amazon Services, LLC
Amazon Services is the operating subsidiary of Amazon.com, Inc. that runs the company's third-party marketplace and related services.
South Carolina Supreme Court
The South Carolina Supreme Court is the state's highest court and issued the ruling affirming the sales tax assessment.
South Carolina Department of Revenue
The South Carolina Department of Revenue is the state agency that administers the state's sales and use taxes and issued the assessment against Amazon.
The details
The Department of Revenue assessed Amazon under the law as it existed in 2016. Amazon controlled product listings, influenced pricing, processed customer payments, handled order notifications and returns, and distributed proceeds to merchants after deducting its fees. The court found the statute unambiguous and held that this level of involvement made Amazon integrally involved in each third-party transaction.
Timeline
January 2016 to March 2016: Period of unpaid sales tax assessed against Amazon.
2019: South Carolina enacted its marketplace facilitator law.
November 15, 2026: South Carolina Supreme Court affirmed the assessment.
Market Landscape
The ruling follows South Carolina's 2019 marketplace facilitator law, which shifted collection duties onto online platforms, and shows the liability that applied to marketplaces before that change. It sets a precedent that platforms with deep transactional control may be treated as sellers even under earlier statutes.
Online shoppers are not directly charged by this ruling, but sellers and marketplaces operating in South Carolina face clearer obligations for collecting and remitting sales tax on third-party transactions. Businesses selling through marketplaces should review how their platform handles tax collection for past and future sales.
The takeaway
Marketplace operators can be held liable as sellers under state tax law when they control transactions closely enough. Merchants and platforms should confirm current state obligations rather than relying on past treatment.
Further reading
For more on how states are handling online marketplace sales, explore Retail coverage on Wisevoter.
Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.
Live Poll
Should online marketplaces like Amazon be required to collect sales tax on third-party sales?









