Court Certifies Builders' Class Action Over Raleigh Fees

North Carolina's Supreme Court affirmed class certification in a suit seeking refunds of Capital Facilities Fees imposed on developers.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Construction

Court Certifies Builders' Class Action Over Raleigh Fees

Live Poll

Should cities have to refund residents for fees they charged unlawfully?

The North Carolina Supreme Court affirmed certification of a class action by home builders seeking refunds of Capital Facilities Fees that the City of Raleigh imposed on developers seeking water and sewer connections between 2016 and 2018. The court rejected the passing-on theory as a basis to defeat class certification.

Why it matters

The ruling allows hundreds of payors and thousands of transactions to be litigated together, which could shape how refund claims against local fees are pursued in North Carolina. The court limited its holding to class certification and did not decide whether the fees were unlawful.

The proposed class spans hundreds of payors and thousands of transactions tied to Capital Facilities Fees imposed from 2016 to 2018. Whether those fees were lawfully imposed has not yet been decided by the court.

The players

City of Raleigh

The city of Raleigh is the municipal government in North Carolina's capital that imposed the Capital Facilities Fees at issue.

The details

Wardson Construction Inc. and other builders sued under N.C.G.S. § 160D-106, which requires that illegal fees be repaid to the person who made the payment. Raleigh argued that many builders passed the fees on to homebuyers, but the court found the statute ties recovery to the act of payment rather than to who bore the economic burden.

Timeline

  1. 2016 to 2018: Raleigh imposed Capital Facilities Fees on developers seeking water and sewer connections.

  2. November 15, 2026: The North Carolina Supreme Court affirmed class certification.

Market Landscape

The decision applies N.C.G.S. § 160D-106, which ties refund rights to the act of payment, to a group of developers challenging municipal infrastructure fees. It places builder refund claims against local governments on a path toward collective adjudication in North Carolina.

Developers and builders who paid Raleigh's Capital Facilities Fees between 2016 and 2018 may be able to pursue refunds through the class action. Whether any refund is ultimately owed depends on a later ruling on whether the fees were unlawful.

The takeaway

Builders who paid municipal infrastructure fees should track whether their payments fall within the affected period, since statutes like N.C.G.S. § 160D-106 tie refund rights to who paid. Collective suits can make small individual claims economically viable.

Further reading

For more on the industry, see Construction coverage across North Carolina.

Live Poll

Should cities have to refund residents for fees they charged unlawfully?