Insurer Must Cover Meijer Defense Costs Above $100K

A Michigan federal judge ruled Meijer's fiduciary liability policy applies to a 2025 lawsuit over 401(k) forfeiture handling.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Insurance

Insurer Must Cover Meijer Defense Costs Above $100K

Judge Hala Y. Jarbou ruled Monday that Hudson Insurance Co. must pay Meijer Inc.'s defense costs above a $100,000 retention in a lawsuit filed in 2025 by Eilionora Donelson, which accuses the grocer of mishandling forfeited money in its 401(k) plan. The lawsuit falls outside the policy's carve-out for excessive fee litigation.

Why it matters

The ruling determines how much Meijer must pay out of pocket before insurance applies to defense costs in the case. Without it, the retention would have been $1 million, a difference that shapes how companies assess coverage for retirement plan litigation.

The ruling reduces Meijer's retention from $1 million to $100,000 for defense costs in the 401(k) forfeiture suit. The underlying allegations against the grocer have not been resolved by the stub's reporting.

The players

Meijer Inc.

Meijer is a Michigan-based grocery and general merchandise retailer operating stores across the Midwest.

Hudson Insurance Co.

Hudson Insurance Co. is the insurer that issued the fiduciary liability policy covering Meijer's retirement plan.

The details

Eilionora Donelson filed the 2025 lawsuit alleging Meijer mishandled forfeited funds in its 401(k) plan. Hudson Insurance Co. issued the fiduciary liability policy, and the court found the suit does not fall within its excessive fee litigation exclusion.

Timeline

  1. 2025: Donelson files lawsuit against Meijer over 401(k) forfeitures.

  2. Monday, November 16, 2026: Judge Hala Y. Jarbou issues insurance coverage ruling.

Insurance Coverage Context

Fiduciary liability policies typically cover claims alleging breaches of duties under ERISA, the federal law governing private retirement plans. Excessive fee carve-outs in such policies determine whether employers bear defense costs directly or shift them to insurers.

Employers and plan sponsors in Michigan should review whether their fiduciary liability policies carve out excessive fee claims, since that exclusion determines who pays defense costs. Participants in workplace 401(k) plans may see more scrutiny of how forfeited funds are handled.

The takeaway

Check your employer's fiduciary liability coverage and retention amounts, since they can change who pays for retirement plan litigation.

Further reading

Explore more on Insurance coverage rules and how liability policies respond to retirement plan lawsuits.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.