Court Denies USP Summary Ruling in Executive Dispute
A Michigan court found factual questions remain in a breach of fiduciary duty claim against a former USP president who later joined a competitor.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Business Strategy

Live Poll
Do you think departing employees should be allowed to take clients to a new employer?
A Michigan court denied USP's motion for summary disposition on liability in its breach of fiduciary duty claim against a former executive. The court said questions of fact remain about his departure, information allegedly taken on a USB drive, and alleged diversion of customers and opportunities.
Why it matters
The ruling means the dispute will proceed to further litigation rather than being resolved on the papers. It highlights how disputes over executive departures, noncompete terms and customer solicitation can turn on contested facts.
The contested bonus figure of $104,000 is part of the dispute, but no damages have been determined. The court has not decided whether the alleged conduct caused harm to the company's customer base.
The players
USP
A Michigan business whose claims against its former president are at the center of the ruling.
Michigan Court
The state court that issued the ruling denying the company's motion for summary disposition on liability.
The details
USP alleges that the former president and a competing firm conspired to steal its customers and divert corporate opportunities, while the former executive says he never signed a noncompete or non-solicitation agreement and that a manager threatened him after he refused to sign one. The court said planning to join a competitor while employed and using public software at the new firm does not by itself amount to a breach of fiduciary duty.
Timeline
Employed by USP from 2015 to 2024, serving as president from 2021 until February 2024.
On February 6, 2024, a manager allegedly asked him to sign a noncompete agreement.
Market Landscape
Disputes over executive departures and noncompete enforcement in Michigan's business community test how far officers may prepare to compete before breaching fiduciary duties. The court's refusal to treat pre-departure planning as a breach narrows one avenue companies have used against departing leaders.
Executives planning a move to a competitor should be careful about contacts and materials taken from their current employer, since those can become evidence in fiduciary duty claims. Employers facing departures should document what they claim was taken and when.
The takeaway
Departing executives should avoid taking company data and document any noncompete terms they were or were not asked to sign, because those facts decide whether fiduciary claims survive. Companies should expect courts to examine the specific conduct behind a departure rather than presume misconduct from a move to a rival.
Further reading
For related coverage, explore Business Strategy reporting across Michigan.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Michigan Lawyers Weekly.
Live Poll
Do you think departing employees should be allowed to take clients to a new employer?










