Court Denies Silvur Injunction Against Former Agent

A Michigan federal judge declined to block insurance agent Jessie Palmer from using information Silvur Insurance Services claims is confidential.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Financial Crime

Court Denies Silvur Injunction Against Former Agent

Silvur Insurance Services LLC sought a preliminary injunction against former employee Jessie Palmer, who it alleges misappropriated trade secrets. The court denied the motion, finding the contract claim unpleaded and ruling on the remaining trade secret request after an evidentiary hearing.

Why it matters

The ruling shapes how former employees in Michigan's insurance sector can handle customer data and commission disputes with former employers. Palmer's attorney holds AgencyBloc reports that she says support unpaid commissions owed by Silvur.

The court denied Silvur's preliminary injunction motion on November 9, 2026, after partially denying it in September for failing to plead breach of contract. The underlying trade secret claims under the Defend Trade Secrets Act and Michigan Uniform Trade Secrets Act have not been resolved.

The players

Silvur Insurance Services LLC

An insurance company that specializes in selling Medicare policies through partnerships with regional credit unions.

Jessie Palmer

A former Silvur employee hired in June 2024 to build the company's Michigan business, who is now contesting the trade secret claims.

The details

Silvur, which sells Medicare policies through regional credit union partnerships, hired Jessie Palmer in June 2024 to build its Michigan business. The company alleges she retained confidential customer data stored in its AgencyBloc database, and Palmer has said she intends to use those reports as evidence Silvur owes her unpaid commissions.

Timeline

  1. June 2024: Silvur hires Jessie Palmer to build its Michigan business.

  2. September 8, 2026: Court partially denies Silvur's motion for failing to plead breach of contract.

  3. September 28, 2026: Court holds evidentiary hearing on the remaining motion.

  4. November 9, 2026: Court denies the remaining preliminary injunction motion on trade secrets.

Legal Context

The case tests how the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016 and Michigan's Uniform Trade Secrets Act apply to customer lists held by departing sales agents. Courts in both systems have repeatedly weighed whether such data qualifies as protectable confidential information.

Insurance agents and employers in Michigan face clearer guidance on how customer data is treated during departures and commission disputes. Customers of regional credit union insurance partnerships are not directly affected by the ruling.

The takeaway

Employers who store customer data in shared systems should document access rules clearly, and departing employees should keep records of any commissions they claim. Disputes like this one are often resolved on the specific pleadings filed early in litigation.

Further reading

For related cases on business data theft, see Financial Crime coverage on Wisevoter.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Michigan Lawyers Weekly.