Judge Fines Attorney Over Sanctions Motion in Oxford Case
The State Appellate Defender's Office has filed a brief supporting attorney Michael Dezsi's appeal of $1,657 in sanctions.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Cheryl Matthews imposed $1,657 in sanctions on attorney Michael Dezsi for filing a motion to disqualify Prosecutor Karen McDonald from the case against an Oxford Township father and an Oxford Township mother. Matthews said she lacked jurisdiction to rule on the disqualification request and called the motion frivolous and redundant.
Why it matters
The sanctions ruling and the appeal test how far defense counsel can go in challenging a prosecutor during post-conviction proceedings in Michigan. The outcome could shape how attorneys in the state raise conduct concerns about prosecutors in high-profile cases.
Judge Cheryl Matthews imposed $1,657 in sanctions on Michael Dezsi for a motion she called frivolous and redundant, and she denied the disqualification request in part for lack of jurisdiction. Dezsi's appeal of the sanctions is scheduled for hearing before the Michigan Court of Appeals on Dec. 8, and whether the appellate court will uphold the penalty has not been decided.
The players
Karen McDonald
Karen McDonald is the Oakland County Prosecutor whose disqualification was sought in the Oxford case and who has publicly rejected the defense's claims as meritless.
Cheryl Matthews
Cheryl Matthews is an Oakland County Circuit Court judge who imposed the sanctions and denied the motion to disqualify the prosecutor.
Michigan State Appellate Defender's Office
The Michigan State Appellate Defender's Office is a state agency that provides appellate representation to indigent defendants and filed the amicus brief supporting Dezsi's appeal.
The details
Dezsi's motion alleged that McDonald violated court rules, entered into secret agreements with two prosecution witnesses, and engaged two public relations firms to run a smear campaign aimed at tainting the jury pool. McDonald called the claims meritless, and Matthews said some issues in the motion had already been raised in the defendants' requests for a new trial or judgment of acquittal. The State Appellate Defender's Office filed an amicus brief supporting Dezsi's appeal.
Timeline
November 2021: Shooting at Oxford High School killed four students, the event underlying the criminal cases.
2024: The Oxford Township parents were sentenced to 10-15 years in prison after being convicted of four counts each of involuntary manslaughter.
Dec. 8: The Michigan Court of Appeals is scheduled to hear Dezsi's sanctions appeal alongside the parents' appeal of their convictions.
Legal Context
The appeal follows the convictions of the parents of the Oxford High School shooter on four counts each of involuntary manslaughter, a case that has drawn statewide attention to parental liability. Post-conviction disputes over prosecutorial conduct in this case now run parallel to the parents' own appeals of their convictions.
Residents of Oakland County and Oxford may follow the appeal's outcome, which could affect how the county's criminal cases proceed on appeal. The hearing on Dec. 8 will be public, and its ruling will determine whether the $1,657 sanction stands.
The takeaway
The case shows that sanctions can follow challenges to prosecutorial conduct even while an appeal is pending, so attorneys weighing such motions face real financial and procedural risk. Readers tracking the Oxford prosecutions can watch the Dec. 8 hearing for the appellate court's view on both the sanctions and the disqualification request.
What happens next
The Michigan Court of Appeals will hear Dezsi's sanctions appeal on Dec. 8, together with the parents' appeal of their involuntary manslaughter convictions.
Further reading
For related coverage, explore Criminal Justice reporting on court rulings and prosecutorial disputes in Michigan.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Detroit News.






