Fourth Circuit Affirms Sacks Holdings' Grin Trademark
A federal appeals panel sided with San Diego-based Sacks Holdings Inc. in its trademark dispute with New Zealand company Grin Natural USA Ltd.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Retail

The Fourth Circuit affirmed that Sacks Holdings Inc., which operates as Grin Oral Care, retains use of the 'Grin' trademark in the United States. The three-judge panel agreed that Grin Natural USA Ltd.'s two small online sales in 2017 did not establish trademark priority.
Why it matters
The ruling confirms that sporadic, unsolicited sales do not by themselves secure trademark rights in the U.S., which matters for foreign companies entering American markets. For consumers and brands in the oral care sector, it reinforces that priority depends on continuous use of a mark in commerce.
The dispute turned on two small, unsolicited online sales made by Grin Natural USA Ltd. in 2017, which the lower court found were not followed by continuous use of the mark in commerce. The filing does not address whether either company plans further appeals or changes to its U.S. sales.
The players
Sacks Holdings Inc.
A San Diego-based company that operates as Grin Oral Care and prevailed in the trademark dispute over the 'Grin' name.
Grin Natural USA Ltd.
A New Zealand company that sought trademark priority in the United States based on its 2017 online sales, which the courts found insufficient.
The details
The Fourth Circuit issued an unpublished decision on Wednesday, agreeing with the lower court that Grin Natural USA Ltd.'s 2017 sales did not establish priority over Sacks Holdings Inc. The panel found no error in the lower court's conclusion that the sales were not followed by sustained use of the mark.
Timeline
2017: Grin Natural USA Ltd. made two small online sales of products under the mark.
November 18, 2026: The Fourth Circuit affirmed the lower court's decision in an unpublished ruling.
Legal Context
The decision applies the Lanham Act's use-based priority rule, which requires continuous use of a mark in commerce rather than isolated sales to establish trademark rights. It reinforces a longstanding U.S. standard that governs how foreign brands can claim names in American retail markets.
For shoppers, the ruling means the Grin toothpaste and oral care products sold under that name in the U.S. are tied to Sacks Holdings Inc. rather than Grin Natural USA Ltd. The decision does not directly change prices or product availability, but it clarifies which company controls the brand in American stores and online.
The takeaway
Trademark rights in the U.S. generally depend on sustained use rather than a few early sales, a point that matters for any brand expanding into American retail. Businesses entering new markets should plan for consistent commercial activity to protect their names.
Further reading
Explore more retail industry coverage for context on how brands compete for shelf and online space.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.





