Federal Circuit Upholds Netlist Memory Patent Invalidation
Appeals court affirms rulings voiding Netlist patents that underpinned a $445 million verdict against Micron Technology.
Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Semiconductors

The Federal Circuit upheld rulings that invalidated Netlist memory chip patents, the patents underlying a $445 million verdict against Micron Technology Inc. The Patent Trial and Appeal Board voided U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417, 9,858,215, and 7,619,912 after challenges by Micron and Samsung Electronics Co.
Why it matters
The ruling removes the patent basis for a large damages award and shows how inter partes challenges at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board can unwind verdicts in the U.S. semiconductor memory market. Netlist has since reached multi-million-dollar settlement agreements with both Micron and Samsung Electronics.
The three voided patents are U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417, 9,858,215, and 7,619,912, covering memory module technology. The Patent Trial and Appeal Board found them invalid, and the Federal Circuit affirmed, while the exact settlement sums remain undisclosed.
The players
Netlist Inc.
Netlist Inc. is a California-based company that designs and sells memory modules and holds patents on high-capacity memory technology used in servers.
Micron Technology Inc.
Micron Technology Inc. is a Boise, Idaho-based semiconductor manufacturer and one of the largest producers of DRAM and NAND memory chips globally.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Samsung Electronics Co. is a South Korea-based technology conglomerate and the world's largest memory chip maker by revenue.
The details
Micron and Samsung Electronics Co. teamed up to challenge the patents at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, which voided the three patents. The Federal Circuit upheld those rulings, undermining the verdict Netlist had won against Micron.
The Tech Race
The Patent Trial and Appeal Board's inter partes review process, created by the America Invents Act of 2011, lets chipmakers challenge patents after issuance and has repeatedly unwound large jury verdicts. Netlist's case against Micron follows that pattern in the memory-chip sector.
Memory chip patent disputes can affect the pricing and availability of server and consumer memory modules over time. Companies that rely on licensed memory designs may face changes to licensing costs as these rulings settle.
The takeaway
Patent challenges at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board can overturn large verdicts, so damages awards in technology cases are only as durable as the patents behind them. Readers following chip supply costs should watch how memory licensing terms evolve after these settlements.
Further reading
Explore more semiconductor industry coverage for context on memory chip competition.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.






