Eighth Circuit Upholds $198,000 Trade Secrets Judgment

A federal appeals court affirmed a judgment against former employee Cody Downing for taking agricultural company information to a rival.

Updated on Nov. 9, 2026 in Agriculture

Eighth Circuit Upholds $198,000 Trade Secrets Judgment

The Eighth Circuit affirmed a $198,000 trade secrets judgment in favor of Wilbur-Ellis Co. against former employee Cody Downing. The court found the Downing case distinguishable from an earlier ruling in which it went against the company.

Why it matters

The decision shows that a company can win a trade secrets case when it specifically identifies protected information and the steps it took to protect it. It also clarifies how this case differs from the earlier Wilbur-Ellis v. Gompert ruling.

The Eighth Circuit affirmed a $198,000 judgment against Cody Downing, who took Wilbur-Ellis information to J.R. Simplot Co. in 2021. The earlier Wilbur-Ellis v. Gompert case involved four other 2021 defections to Simplot, while the outcome of any post-ruling payment or appeal remains unreported.

The players

Wilbur-Ellis Co.

Wilbur-Ellis Co. is an agricultural products company that brought the trade secrets claims against its former employee.

Eighth Circuit

The Eighth Circuit is the federal appeals court covering several Midwestern and Plains states, which issued the ruling.

The details

Downing took Wilbur-Ellis information to J.R. Simplot Co. in 2021. Wilbur-Ellis identified the information subject to protection and outlined the steps it took to protect it, which the court found sufficient in this case.

Timeline

  1. 2021: Downing took information to Simplot, and four other defections occurred in the related Gompert case.

  2. November 9, 2026: The Eighth Circuit affirmed the $198,000 Downing judgment.

Legal Context

The Eighth Circuit previously ruled against Wilbur-Ellis in Wilbur-Ellis v. Gompert for not identifying the stolen trade secrets with enough specificity. This decision marks a contrast, showing the company prevailed when it specifically identified protected information and the protective steps it took.

Companies that rely on confidential operational information can use this ruling as a reminder to document exactly what they protect and how. Employees and contractors should understand that taking proprietary information to a competitor can lead to a court judgment.

The takeaway

Businesses protecting trade secrets should clearly identify the protected information and document their safeguards, since courts look for that specificity. The Downing and Gompert rulings together show that the strength of a trade secrets claim often depends on the quality of the evidence presented.

Further reading

For related coverage, see more Agriculture industry news.