Medefy Finds 40% to 55% of Medical Spend Is Fixable

Claims research on four self-funded employer health plans points to lower-cost care sites as a major source of avoidable spending.

Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Healthcare

Medefy Finds 40% to 55% of Medical Spend Is Fixable

Live Poll

Is now a good time for your employer to change its health plan?

Medefy released claims research finding that 40% to 55% of self-funded medical spend is fixable, with an average of 47% across four plans covering more than 11 million claim lines. Three of the four plans analyzed are not Medefy clients.

Why it matters

The research indicates that much of the Q4 spending increase came from where members were routed for care, not from contracting failures, since one plan had negotiated better than 50% off billed charges. Employers facing rising benefit costs may find routing decisions a more immediate lever than plan design changes.

The research covers four self-funded plans and more than 11 million claim lines, with the fixable share averaging 47%. Q4 claim volume rose 2% to 5% while cost per claim rose 6% to 7%, and how much of that spend can be recovered in future plan years remains unresolved.

The players

Medefy

A healthcare cost-management company whose claims research analyzed four self-funded employer health plans, three of which are not its clients.

Marsh

A global insurance broker and consultant whose annual National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans projects employer health cost trends.

Health Care Cost Institute

A nonprofit research organization that publishes analyses of U.S. health care spending and prices.

The details

Members in the analyzed plans were routed to higher-cost facilities within the same network, paying nothing out of pocket at either site. Medefy reported that about half of the Q4 increase was mechanical, driven by members meeting their deductibles, and that laparoscopic hysterectomy, cataract surgery and chest X-rays drove the volume rise.

Timeline

  1. April 2026: Health Care Cost Institute issued a brief finding imaging prices at hospital outpatient departments ran two to four times higher than at physician offices.

  2. October 2026: Advisors are urged to pull scheduled Q4 procedures before the quarter begins.

  3. 2027: Employer health benefit costs are projected to rise 8.2% per employee, according to Marsh's 2026 National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans.

Market Landscape

The Medefy findings extend the April 2026 Health Care Cost Institute brief, which documented hospital outpatient imaging prices running two to four times higher than physician offices, into measured employer-plan spending. Together they point to site-of-care routing as a central competitive lever among plan administrators and benefit consultants.

Employers and benefits managers may find that routing members to lower-cost imaging and surgical sites can reduce plan-paid spending without changing benefits. Advisors may want to review scheduled Q4 procedures before the quarter begins to steer members toward lower-cost facilities.

The takeaway

Site-of-care routing is a practical lever for employers, since the same procedure can cost nearly half as much at a lower-cost facility within the same network. Benefits teams can act on it before renewal season.

What happens next

Employers and advisors can review scheduled Q4 procedures before the quarter begins in October 2026, and the 8.2% projected 2027 cost increase will shape plan renewal decisions.

Further reading

Explore more Healthcare coverage on how employer plan costs are shaped by site-of-care decisions.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Insurance Business.

Live Poll

Is now a good time for your employer to change its health plan?