Wakely Study Models CHOICE Adoption in Three States

An October 2026 white paper by Wakely Consulting Group estimates how small employers switching to CHOICE arrangements could shift ACA marketplace enrollment.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Employment

Flat-color editorial illustration of a steel balance scale with the lower pan weighed down by a single glass sphere against a cream background.
Wakely Consulting Group's October 2026 white paper finds a $50-per-employee monthly vendor fee would erase CHOICE's premium savings for employers in Iowa. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Would you say health insurance costs are getting better or worse for you?

Wakely Consulting Group published an October 2026 white paper modeling adoption of CHOICE arrangements in South Carolina, Iowa, and Tennessee. The analysis finds that a $50-per-employee-per-month vendor fee can erase the premium savings CHOICE offers in Iowa.

Why it matters

CHOICE lets employers fund individual reimbursement accounts that workers use to buy ACA marketplace coverage, a model that shifts more coverage risk onto employees than traditional group plans. The modeling suggests the financial case for employers depends heavily on state premium gaps and administrative fees.

The modeling is an actuarial estimate of enrollment under scenarios in which small employers switch to CHOICE at varying premium savings thresholds, with South Carolina's individual ACA premiums at least 50% above small group rates in 2027 and Iowa's priced much closer together. Estimated South Carolina enrollment gains of 2.4% to 7.6% contrast with 0.0% to 0.3% in Iowa, and the final CMS rule could change these projections.

The players

Wakely Consulting Group

Wakely Consulting Group is an actuarial and consulting firm that publishes analyses of health insurance markets and policy.

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)

CMS is the federal agency that administers the ACA marketplaces and is responsible for issuing the forthcoming CHOICE rule.

Paul Fronstin

Paul Fronstin is a researcher at the Employee Benefit Research Institute who has analyzed how CHOICE shifts coverage risk onto employees.

The details

Wakely actuaries Taylor Gehrke, Michael Cohen, and Kayla Zimdars modeled CHOICE adoption in South Carolina, Iowa, and Tennessee. In Iowa, a $50-per-employee-per-month vendor fee, consistent with pricing from at least one CHOICE platform administrator, eliminates the premium advantage CHOICE would otherwise provide.

Timeline

  1. 2026: The TASC 2026 Broker ICHRA Survey finds more than half of benefits brokers have never sold the product, while employer adoption passes 20,000 businesses.

  2. October 2026: Wakely publishes its white paper modeling CHOICE adoption.

  3. Late 2026 or early 2027: CMS is expected to release new CHOICE guidance.

  4. 2027: The modeled South Carolina individual ACA premium gap applies.

Roadmap

CHOICE arrangements route employer-funded reimbursements into the individual ACA marketplace created under the Affordable Care Act, extending that exchange's role in how employer-sponsored coverage is delivered. The model's growth past 20,000 employers in 2026 sits alongside the marketplace's ongoing competition with traditional group plans for small-business workers.

Small employers weighing CHOICE must compare the vendor fee, such as the $50 per employee per month cited in the modeling, against the premium gap in their state before switching. Employees who receive a CHOICE reimbursement take on more of the coverage risk than they would in a traditional group plan.

The takeaway

The economics of CHOICE depend less on the model itself than on local premium gaps and administrative fees, so employers should run state-specific numbers before committing. Workers should understand that this arrangement moves more coverage risk onto them.

What happens next

CMS is expected to release new CHOICE guidance in late 2026 or early 2027, and Wakely has committed to a follow-up analysis once the rule is published.

Further reading

For the broader labor-market context around employer-sponsored benefits, see Employment coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Insurance Business.

Live Poll

Would you say health insurance costs are getting better or worse for you?