Pak-A-Sak Drops Local Products After Casey's Takeover
Local favorites The Cake Company fried pies and Grandma's Burritos are no longer sold at former Pak-A-Sak stores in Amarillo.
Updated on Nov. 7, 2026 in Openings & Closings
Live Poll
Do you think your area is losing its local businesses?
Pak-A-Sak convenience stores were sold to Casey's, and the transition has removed The Cake Company fried pies and Grandma's Burritos from those locations. The Cake Company pies have moved to Toot'n Totum stores.
Why it matters
The stores are transitioning to Casey's following the sale of Pak-A-Sak, which has ended local product offerings at the former Pak-A-Sak locations. Amarillo shoppers who relied on these local items now need to find them at other retailers.
The Cake Company fried pies are now sold at 10 Toot'n Totum locations, after they were stocked at Pak-A-Sak starting in April 2026. Casey's has not responded to a request from the publication about whether local businesses can continue carrying products in the stores.
The players
Casey's
Casey's is a Midwestern convenience store chain that acquired the Pak-A-Sak locations in Amarillo.
Toot'n Totum
Toot'n Totum is a regional convenience store chain in the Texas Panhandle that now carries The Cake Company fried pies.
The details
Pak-A-Sak locations stopped carrying The Cake Company pies as they transitioned to Casey's, and Grandma's Burritos are no longer available there after October 30. Shoppers can now buy The Cake Company pies at its Canyon shop at 1502 5th Ave. and Grandma's Burritos at 7012 S. Western St. and 8700 Clinton Glenn Rd.
Timeline
April 2026: The Cake Company began selling fried pies at Pak-A-Sak.
August 2026: Readers were informed that Pak-A-Sak stores were sold to Casey's.
October 30, 2026: Grandma's Burritos stopped being available at Pak-A-Sak.
Market Landscape
The Pak-A-Sak sale to Casey's is part of a wider pattern of regional convenience store chains absorbing independent operators. Local food brands in the Texas Panhandle now depend on the purchasing decisions of acquiring chains to keep their products on store shelves.
Amarillo shoppers who bought The Cake Company fried pies or Grandma's Burritos at Pak-A-Sak will need to visit the Canyon shop, Toot'n Totum, or the Western Street and Clinton Glenn Road locations instead. Whether local products return to Casey's shelves has not been confirmed.
The takeaway
Local shoppers who want their favorite regional products should check other retailers before assuming they will remain at a store after a sale. Following availability directly with a store or brand can prevent a wasted trip.
Further reading
For more on store changes like this, see Openings & Closings in Amarillo.
Source note: This article includes information reported by 96.9 KISS FM.
Live Poll
Do you think your area is losing its local businesses?
