Former Player Appeals Defamation Ruling to Supreme Court

A former college baseball player has appealed a trial court decision favoring two media companies in his defamation lawsuit.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Former Player Appeals Defamation Ruling to Supreme Court

A former college baseball player involved in a 2023 hazing incident in Rapid City has appealed a trial court ruling in his defamation lawsuit against Nexstar and Forum Communications. Appeal documents were received by the South Dakota Supreme Court on November 18.

Why it matters

The appeal sends the dispute over Keloland's reporting on the hazing case to the state's highest court for review. The outcome could clarify how defamation claims tied to coverage of a criminal matter are handled in South Dakota.

The appeal is pending before the South Dakota Supreme Court, which received documents on November 18 and lists the case as not ready for hearing. No hearing date or ruling timeline has been set.

The players

Nexstar

Nexstar is a major American television broadcasting company that owns and operates local news stations across the country.

Forum Communications

Forum Communications is a North Dakota-based media company that owns newspapers and broadcast properties across the Upper Midwest.

The details

The lawsuit alleges defamation over articles and television broadcasts published by Keloland. After the trial court sided with Nexstar and Forum Communications, the plaintiff filed an appeal, and the case remains at an early procedural stage.

Timeline

  1. 2023: Hazing incident occurs in a Rapid City hotel room.

  2. 2024: The former player pleads guilty to one count of accessory to a felony under a plea deal.

  3. November 18, 2026: Appeal documents are received by the South Dakota Supreme Court.

Legal Context

Defamation suits over local news coverage of criminal cases are typically decided on whether reporting was accurate and whether the plaintiff can show harm. The state Supreme Court's review could set the standard for how similar claims against broadcasters are handled in South Dakota.

Residents of South Dakota who follow local news may be affected by the ruling's standard for reporting on criminal cases. The appeal's outcome could influence how local outlets approach coverage of ongoing legal matters.

The takeaway

Court appeals in defamation cases can take considerable time before a ruling, so readers should expect the Supreme Court process to unfold over months. Following official court dockets offers the most reliable updates.

Further reading

Explore more criminal justice coverage for context on court proceedings in South Dakota.

Source note: This article includes information reported by KYNT-AM.