Supreme Court Revives Church Suit Over $900,000 Gifts

The South Dakota Supreme Court reversed a circuit court ruling and sent a dispute over blank-payee donation checks back for new proceedings.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Philanthropy

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a brass donation box on a ledge before a stone pedestal, with blank cream cards, evoking a legal dispute over donated funds.
The South Dakota Supreme Court reversed a lower ruling and sent a church's $900,000 donation-check dispute with a Mitchell pastor back to circuit court for new proceedings. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust your local church leaders to handle donations as donors intend?

The South Dakota Supreme Court overturned a lower court ruling that favored a church in a dispute with a Mitchell pastor over three $300,000 donation checks. The court remanded the case to circuit court for new proceedings.

Why it matters

The ruling indicates that the lower court did not fully consider the pastor's fraud claim, which relied in part on a parishioner's affidavit stating one check was intended for him personally. The case shows how blank-payee checks can become central to disputes over who a donation was meant to benefit.

The donation consisted of three $300,000 checks, totaling $900,000, written in 2022. Two of the three checks were left blank in the payee line, and the final resolution of how the funds are divided has not been determined.

The players

Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida

A Pentecostal church founded in Columbus, Nebraska, in 2009 that operates parishes in South Dakota and is at the center of this dispute over donated funds.

South Dakota Supreme Court

The state's highest court, which reviewed the lower court's ruling and sent the donation dispute back to circuit court for new proceedings.

The details

A parishioner wrote three $300,000 checks in 2022, one payable to Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida with 'tithe' in the memo line and two with the payee line blank and 'mission' in the memo line. The two blank-payee checks were given to pastors at the church's Mitchell and Yankton parishes, and one pastor deposited his check into the church account before allegedly transferring money to his own account. The church sued for conversion and breach of fiduciary duty, and the pastor countersued on claims of conversion and fraud.

Timeline

  1. 2009: Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida was founded in Columbus, Nebraska.

  2. 2022: The parishioner wrote the three $300,000 donation checks.

  3. November 13, 2026: The South Dakota Supreme Court released its ruling and remanded the case to circuit court.

Market Landscape

Disputes over church donations held by individual clergy fit a broader pattern in which religious organizations face scrutiny over how gifts are handled and recorded. The South Dakota case shows how state courts apply conversion and fiduciary duty standards to religious giving when the payee designation is missing.

Donors who write checks to churches or clergy should confirm the payee and memo line are completed, since blank-payee checks can lead to lengthy litigation over who received the money. Congregation members may also want to ask how their gifts are deposited and tracked.

The takeaway

Clear payee designations on donation checks can prevent disputes over where gifts are meant to go. Donors who give large sums to religious organizations should document the intended recipient in writing.

Further reading

For related coverage of giving and charitable organizations, see Philanthropy on Wisevoter.

Source note: This article includes information reported by SDPB.

Live Poll

Do you trust your local church leaders to handle donations as donors intend?