Supreme Court Weighs New Trial in 1984 Double Murder

South Dakota's high court is reviewing a Rapid City judge's order granting an 84-year-old man a new trial based on DNA evidence.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Abstract editorial illustration in slate and cream with a single oxblood accent, showing a plain columned courthouse facade against open prairie sky.
South Dakota's Supreme Court is reviewing a Rapid City judge's order granting an 84-year-old man a new trial in a 1984 double murder based on DNA evidence. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The South Dakota Supreme Court is considering whether an 84-year-old man convicted in a 1984 double murder should receive a new trial. A Rapid City judge ordered the new trial after DNA testing conducted decades after the conviction, and the state Attorney General's Office has appealed that order.

Why it matters

The case could clarify how South Dakota courts apply the state's law allowing new trials based on newly discovered DNA evidence. The man has spent more than four decades in prison, so the outcome will directly affect whether he faces a retrial.

The state Supreme Court has the appeal of the Rapid City new-trial order under consideration, with no ruling issued yet. The double-murder conviction from 1984 remains in place while the appeal is pending.

The players

South Dakota Supreme Court

The state's highest court, which is reviewing whether the Rapid City new-trial order should stand.

South Dakota Attorney General's Office

The state agency that appealed the Rapid City judge's order granting a new trial.

The details

Prosecutors convicted the man in 1984 in the deaths of his estranged wife and her mother, which occurred in 1983. Trial evidence included alleged threats and circumstantial evidence linking him to the crime, while later DNA testing excluded him from key evidence at the scene. His attorneys argue the DNA results, combined with other factors, could change the outcome of a retrial.

Timeline

  1. 1983: The double murder of the estranged wife and her mother occurred.

  2. 1984: The man was convicted in the deaths.

  3. Nov. 12, 2026: The South Dakota Supreme Court is scheduled to consider the new-trial question.

Legal Context

The appeal asks how South Dakota's statute permitting new trials for newly discovered DNA evidence applies to a decades-old conviction. The Supreme Court's reasoning could shape how similar post-conviction DNA claims are handled in state courts.

The ruling will determine whether the man receives a retrial or remains imprisoned under the original conviction. Residents interested in how DNA evidence is used in state post-conviction review can follow the court's decision when it is issued.

The takeaway

Post-conviction DNA testing can raise serious questions about older verdicts, and courts must weigh new scientific evidence against the original trial record. The Supreme Court's decision will show how South Dakota balances those competing concerns.

What happens next

The South Dakota Supreme Court is scheduled to consider the new-trial question on November 12, 2026.

Further reading

Explore more coverage of Criminal Justice cases across South Dakota.

Source note: This article includes information reported by NEWS RADIO KOTA-AM 1380AM/100.7FM.