Supreme Court Weighs Circuit Court Consolidation

South Dakota's high court heard final public comments on a proposal to merge the fourth and seventh judicial circuits.

Updated on Nov. 9, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Isometric editorial illustration of a modest civic building on an open prairie plane, with a single empty podium block in the foreground.
The South Dakota Supreme Court heard final public comments in Pierre on a proposal to merge the fourth and seventh judicial circuits, with most speakers opposed. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think South Dakota's court system is serving your area well now?

The South Dakota Supreme Court heard final public comments in Pierre on consolidating the fourth and seventh judicial circuits. Most speakers opposed the proposal, and a decision is nearing.

Why it matters

The proposal would shift judicial resources across the state, with the revised Fourth Circuit holding 29 percent of South Dakota's judges. State officials say it aims to balance growing urban needs with maintaining rural services.

Survey data from statewide attorneys presented by Lora Waeckerle showed a majority opposed the merger, with the deepest opposition in the Fourth and Seventh circuits. The Supreme Court's final ruling on the proposal remains pending.

The players

Greg Sattizahn

South Dakota State Court Administrator who was the lone proponent of the circuit consolidation among public comment speakers.

Lora Waeckerle

Rapid City-based attorney who presented survey data from attorneys statewide on the proposal.

Eric Strawn

South Dakota circuit judge who presides in Deadwood.

The details

The public comment session at the Capitol in Pierre included speakers mostly opposed to the plan, with State Court Administrator Greg Sattizahn the lone proponent. Sattizahn said demands from the largest counties, Meade and Pennington, are notable considerations in the proposal.

Timeline

  1. Monday: Public comment session on circuit consolidation held at the Capitol in Pierre.

  2. Nov. 9, 2026: Final Supreme Court arguments on the proposal reported.

Criminal Justice Context

The proposal would reshape the existing South Dakota Unified Judicial System circuit structure by merging the fourth and seventh circuits. The reform seeks to address shifting caseload pressures between urban and rural courts.

Residents in the affected circuits could see changes in which courts handle their cases and where judges are assigned. Court access in rural counties such as Corson and Harding may be affected by the outcome.

The takeaway

Court structure decisions shape how quickly and where residents can access justice, so monitoring the Supreme Court's ruling helps readers understand changes to their local courts.

Further reading

Explore more South Dakota criminal justice coverage on how court structure affects local courts.

Live Poll

Do you think South Dakota's court system is serving your area well now?