Appeals Court Upholds Rock Hill Short-Term Rental Rules
The Fourth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the city in a challenge to its short-term rental ordinances.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Apartments

Live Poll
Should your city be able to limit short-term rentals in residential neighborhoods?
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the City of Rock Hill in a challenge to ordinances regulating short-term rentals. The ordinances, adopted between 2020 and 2023, impose permitting requirements and limit short-term rentals to certain zones.
Why it matters
The ruling lets Rock Hill keep enforcing zoning and permitting limits on short-term rentals, including a five-year phase-out of nonconforming properties. It signals that courts will apply deferential review to local rental regulation challenged on due process, equal protection and commerce grounds.
The ruling covers ordinances adopted between 2020 and 2023 that require permits for short-term rentals and limit them to certain zones. Nonconforming properties are being phased out over a five-year amortization period, and the status of any further appeal is not stated.
The players
City of Rock Hill
Rock Hill is a city in York County, South Carolina, located just south of Charlotte, North Carolina.
The details
The plaintiff, who operated several short-term rentals booked through platforms including Airbnb, challenged the ordinances on several grounds. The Fourth Circuit held the plaintiff lacked standing to assert claims on behalf of out-of-state guests, rejected the First Amendment retaliation, due process, equal protection and Dormant Commerce Clause claims, and applied rational-basis review.
Timeline
2020-2023: Rock Hill adopts the short-term rental ordinances challenged in the suit.
Five-year amortization period: nonconforming short-term rental properties are phased out.
Legal Context
The Fourth Circuit's deferential rational-basis review of the ordinances follows the standard courts have long applied to municipal zoning, extending it to short-term rental regulation. Local governments across the region continue to face similar challenges as they adopt permitting and zoning limits on short-term rentals.
Rock Hill residents who operate short-term rentals must comply with the permitting requirements and zone limits, and nonconforming properties will be phased out over five years. Neighbors of short-term rentals may see continued enforcement of the city's noise and congestion rules.
The takeaway
Local short-term rental rules are likely to hold up in court when they treat in-state and out-of-state operators alike and rest on a rational basis such as protecting housing stock. Property owners should check current zoning before investing in short-term rental units.
Further reading
For more on housing rules in the region, see Apartments in Rock Hill.
Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.
Live Poll
Should your city be able to limit short-term rentals in residential neighborhoods?










