Appeals Court Revives Lawsuit Against Cleveland Officers

A three-judge panel reversed a dismissal of Latrice Carter's suit over the 2024 police shooting that killed her daughter, Antwonia Carter.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Law Enforcement

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a stone civic building with tall columns standing alone under a gray sky, evoking institutional accountability.
Cleveland's appeals court revived a lawsuit by Latrice Carter against two police officers who fired into a car that killed her daughter, Antwonia Carter, in 2024. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The 8th District Court of Appeals revived a lawsuit by Latrice Carter against Cleveland police officers Dylan O'Donnell and Amanda Rock, reversing a Cuyahoga County Common Pleas judge's dismissal of the case. The suit alleges negligent infliction of emotional distress over the March 17, 2024 shooting that killed Antwonia Carter, 26.

Why it matters

The ruling sends the case back to the trial court, allowing the claims over the officers' actions to proceed toward a decision on the merits. It highlights how officers' fire into a moving vehicle can lead to civil liability even when authorities determined another person caused the death.

The case was filed in July 2025, dismissed by a Cuyahoga County Common Pleas judge, and revived by the 8th District Court of Appeals in a three-judge decision. It now returns to the trial court in Cuyahoga County, where the claims against O'Donnell and Rock have not yet been resolved.

The players

Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court

The trial court in Cuyahoga County that originally dismissed the lawsuit and will hear the case again after the appellate ruling.

8th District Court of Appeals

The Ohio appellate court whose three-judge panel reversed the dismissal and sent the case back for further proceedings.

The details

Antwonia Carter was driving near East 105th Street and Garfield Avenue when a gunman opened fire on her car, then drove past her mother's house where police had been dispatched. Officers O'Donnell and Rock fired at the moving car, believing the gunfire was coming from it; authorities determined the gunman, not the officers, killed her.

Timeline

  1. March 17, 2024: Antwonia Carter is shot and killed near East 105th Street and Garfield Avenue.

  2. July 2025: Latrice Carter files the lawsuit against the officers.

  3. August: O'Donnell resigns from Cleveland police in good standing.

  4. November 2026: The appeals court reverses the dismissal and revives the lawsuit.

Legal Context

The ruling reflects how Ohio courts evaluate negligent infliction of emotional distress claims against officers who fire into vehicles, a question that often turns on whether the officers' conduct created foreseeable harm. Cases like this test the boundary between officer discretion under use-of-force policies and civil accountability for family members affected by police gunfire.

Cleveland residents who live near high-traffic areas where police respond to shootings may see the case shape how officers are held accountable for shots fired at moving vehicles. The ruling keeps the lawsuit alive, meaning the officers could face further legal scrutiny in local courts.

The takeaway

The ruling shows that a civil case can continue even after authorities identify a different person as the one who caused a death. Readers following police accountability in Cleveland can watch how the Cuyahoga County court handles the claims on remand.

What happens next

The case returns to the Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court for further proceedings, with no date yet set.

Further reading

For more on accountability in police conduct, see Law Enforcement coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Cleveland.