Brooklyn Court Awards Stutchin Name to Yudkowsky
A special bais din ruled that Rav Eliezer Yehoshua Yudkowsky alone may use the Stutchin name in a dispute between two chassidic courts.
Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Judaism

A special Brooklyn bais din, headed by Rav Shimon Yitzchok Schlesinger of the Eidah HaChareidis, awarded exclusive use of the Stutchin name to Rav Eliezer Yehoshua Yudkowsky. The ruling ordered Rav Mordechai Menashe Zilber's court to identify itself exclusively as Ropshitz-Stutchin.
Why it matters
The decision settles which of two Stutchiner chassidic courts may claim the name and institutional legacy of the previous Stutchiner Rebbe. It also resolves a dispute that had led to multiple injunctions issued by various botei din.
The bais din required the words Ropshitz and Stutchin to appear in equally prominent lettering and identical size. The ruling is a binding decision of a special Brooklyn bais din arbitration panel, and its implementation timeline is not specified.
The players
Rav Eliezer Yehoshua Yudkowsky
A chassidic rabbi awarded exclusive use of the Stutchin name and publication rights to Menchas Yehuda by the Brooklyn bais din.
Rav Mordechai Menashe Zilber
A chassidic rabbi whose court was ordered to identify itself exclusively as Ropshitz-Stutchin and to stop operating under the name Toldos Yehuda.
Rav Shimon Yitzchok Schlesinger
A rabbi of the Eidah HaChareidis who headed the special bais din that issued the ruling.
The details
Both chassidic courts signed a formal agreement to submit their disagreements to a panel of dayanim. The panel ruled that Rav Zilber's court may no longer operate under the name Toldos Yehuda, but may continue publishing works on the history and teachings of the Stutchin dynasty under the Ropshitz-Stutchin name.
Timeline
No specific dates for the ruling or its implementation are stated in the source material.
Religious Institution Context
Rabbinic arbitration by the Eidah HaChareidis, a Haredi body that has long resolved communal disputes internally, is applied here to a succession fight over the Stutchin name. The ruling places the Brooklyn bais din within that established tradition of internal adjudication.
Members and followers of the two Stutchiner courts in Brooklyn will need to follow the new naming requirements, including the equal-prominence lettering rule. Readers interested in Stutchin publications should note that Menchas Yehuda now belongs exclusively to Rav Yudkowsky.
The takeaway
Internal rabbinic arbitration can resolve long-running succession disputes while leaving room for both courts to continue their historical work under distinct names.
Further reading
For more on the religious traditions behind this ruling, explore Judaism coverage on Wisevoter.










