Judge Admonished Over Trash Fine Dispute
New York's Commission on Judicial Conduct disciplined Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Katherine Levine for repeatedly invoking her judicial title while contesting sanitation fines.
Updated on Nov. 3, 2026 in Corruption

Live Poll
Do you trust local government officials to follow the same rules as everyone else?
The New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct issued an admonition to Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Katherine Levine after she spent 20 months contesting three sanitation violations totaling $150. Levine repeatedly invoked her judicial title during the dispute and eventually paid the fines.
Why it matters
The case highlights how judges are expected to avoid using their office to seek special treatment in ordinary legal matters, even minor ones. For Brooklyn residents, it underscores that the same sanitation rules apply to everyone, including those on the bench.
The commission issued a formal admonition on November 3, 2026, and Levine has since paid the fines, which had grown to $650 through missed hearings. The matter has been resolved administratively, with no further charges reported in the extraction.
The players
Katherine Levine
Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice who has sat on the bench since 2008 and was admonished for invoking her judicial title while contesting trash fines.
New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct
The state body responsible for investigating and disciplining judges in New York, which issued the admonition against Levine.
Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings
New York City's administrative tribunal that adjudicates sanitation and other civil violations, where Levine's trash fines were contested.
The details
Sanitation workers found trash accumulated at Levine's Borough Park home in March 2024, and she responded with an online not-guilty plea referencing her Supreme Court position. The commission found her repeated references to her judicial office created the appearance she sought special treatment, despite her clean disciplinary record since joining the bench in 2008.
Timeline
March 2024: Sanitation workers discovered trash accumulation at the Borough Park home.
Spring 2025: Levine received two additional fines for uncovered trash receptacles.
October 2025: Levine left a voicemail for OATH stating 'Hi this is Judge Katherine Levine.'
Monday, November 3, 2026: The Commission released its admonition.
Legal Context
The case applies New York's Rules Governing Judicial Conduct, which prohibit judges from using their office to seek personal advantage, to an ordinary sanitation dispute. It shows the commission enforcing those standards even when the underlying fines were only $150.
Residents facing city sanitation citations can contest them through OATH, but the case shows that invoking a government title does not exempt anyone from the process. Fines that go unpaid or unanswered can grow substantially through missed hearings.
The takeaway
Equal application of sanitation rules matters most when the person accused holds public trust. Residents who receive city violations should respond on time, because unanswered fines can escalate quickly regardless of who they are.
Further reading
For related coverage of official misconduct, see Corruption reporting.
Live Poll
Do you trust local government officials to follow the same rules as everyone else?










