BPL Plans New Sheepshead Bay Library Branch

Brooklyn Public Library will build a consolidated branch at 2685 Coney Island Avenue, replacing the Sheepshead Bay and Homecrest libraries.

Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Openings & Closings

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain civic building beside a cleared lot and stacked construction materials, evoking a new public library under construction.
Brooklyn Public Library plans to replace its Sheepshead Bay and Homecrest branches with a new consolidated library at 2685 Coney Island Avenue, slated to open in 2030. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think your local public library branches are being well maintained?

Brooklyn Public Library announced plans for a new Sheepshead Bay branch at 2685 Coney Island Avenue, slated to open in 2030. The facility will replace the existing Sheepshead Bay and Homecrest libraries, which sit less than a mile apart.

Why it matters

The current branch buildings are leased rather than owned by the library, and leased buildings are not eligible for city-funded capital improvements. Building problems have also caused repeated unplanned closures at the Homecrest Library over the past three years.

BPL bought the four adjacent commercial buildings at 2685 Coney Island Avenue for just under $5 million, while bringing the Homecrest Library up to standard would cost at least $16 million. The new facility's total construction cost and final square footage have not been disclosed.

The players

Brooklyn Public Library

The Brooklyn Public Library is a major public library system serving the borough of Brooklyn, New York, with dozens of neighborhood branches.

The details

The new library will replace the Sheepshead Bay and Homecrest branches, both of which serve large immigrant populations and have among the least-leased collections in the borough. Construction is slated to begin in 2028, and a public engagement process will begin in winter.

Timeline

  1. The Sheepshead Bay Library first opened in 1903 and moved to its current location in 1963.

  2. The Homecrest Library opened on Coney Island Avenue in 1963.

  3. A public engagement process will begin in winter 2026-2027.

  4. Construction is slated to begin in 2028.

  5. The Homecrest Library will close in 2029, and the Sheepshead Bay Library will shutter the following summer.

Roadmap

The plan reflects a broader pattern in which urban library systems replace older leased storefronts with larger, owned buildings to qualify for capital funding. It follows the library system's recent investments in renovating and expanding other Brooklyn branches.

Residents of Sheepshead Bay and Homecrest will see their two nearby branches consolidated into one larger facility by 2030. Those who rely on the Homecrest Library should expect closure in 2029 before the new site opens.

The takeaway

Library consolidation can trade two aging leased branches for one larger, publicly controlled building that qualifies for capital investment. Residents should watch the upcoming public engagement process for details on the new facility's design.

What happens next

A public engagement process on the new Sheepshead Bay branch will begin in winter 2026-2027, and construction is slated to begin in 2028.

Further reading

Explore more Brooklyn openings and closings to see other neighborhood business changes.

Live Poll

Do you think your local public library branches are being well maintained?