Board Denies 56-Unit Apartment Plan on Route 9

Toms River's zoning board voted 6 to 1 against a proposed three-story apartment building, and the developer has sued to win approval.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in City Hall

Wooded coastal-plain land beside a wide road, with a weathered survey stake and orange safety fencing at the forest edge under overcast light.
The Toms River zoning board voted 6 to 1 on Tuesday to deny a 56-unit apartment plan at Route 9 and West Whitty Road, prompting the developer to sue for approval. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should your town approve new apartments even when traffic concerns are raised?

The Toms River Board of Adjustment voted 6 to 1 to deny a plan by a Toms River area developer to build 56 apartment units at Route 9 and West Whitty Road. The developer has sued the board and the township seeking approval.

Why it matters

The decision affects how a 35-acre site in Toms River may be developed, including whether 12 affordable units are added to the township's housing stock. Board members cited traffic concerns on crowded Route 9 among their reasons for denial.

The board voted 6 to 1 to deny the 56-unit plan, which would include 12 affordable units on a 35-acre parcel already home to 175 units. Whether the Ocean County Superior Court will order approval remains unresolved until the case goes to trial.

The players

Toms River Board of Adjustment

The local zoning body in Toms River that reviews land-use applications and voted to deny the apartment plan.

Francis R. Hodgson Jr.

A Superior Court assignment judge who is scheduled to preside over the trial of the developer's lawsuit.

The details

The proposed three-story building would replace part of the Green Meadows at Pleasant Plains complex, which has 175 apartments and townhouses. The developer asked an Ocean County Superior Court judge to overturn the denial, and the zoning board's chairman pointed to the site's earlier 2013 application for 252 apartments, litigation, and a settlement that allowed 175 units.

Timeline

  1. 2013: A 252-apartment application on the parcel was denied by the board.

  2. 2024: The zoning board approved a 46,000-square-foot commercial center on the site.

  3. December 11, 2026: Trial is scheduled before Superior Court Assignment Judge Francis R. Hodgson Jr.

Political Context

The denial continues a long pattern on this parcel, where a 2013 application for 252 apartments was rejected and litigation ultimately produced a settlement capping development at 175 units. Opponents of higher density point to the same Route 9 traffic concerns that shaped the current vote.

Residents near Route 9 and West Whitty Road face a possible change in neighborhood density and traffic depending on how the lawsuit is resolved. The outcome will determine whether the 12 proposed affordable units are added to the township.

The takeaway

Zoning disputes on contested parcels often hinge on traffic and density arguments that recur across multiple applications. Readers following Toms River land use should watch the December trial date for a final ruling.

What happens next

The lawsuit seeking approval of the plan is scheduled for trial on December 11, 2026, before Superior Court Assignment Judge Francis R. Hodgson Jr.

Further reading

For more on local land-use decisions, see City Hall coverage in Toms River.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Asbury Park Press.

Live Poll

Should your town approve new apartments even when traffic concerns are raised?