Toms River Sues Prosecutor Over Police Oversight

The township alleges Ocean County prosecutors interfere with its police department's operations, a claim the prosecutor's office disputes.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Law Enforcement

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of two plain municipal buildings divided by a single red line, illustrating a jurisdictional dispute over police oversight.
Toms River sued Ocean County Prosecutor Bradley Billhimer and First Assistant Prosecutor Michael T. Nolan Jr. over claims the prosecutor's office interferes with township police operations. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Toms River has filed a legal argument contending the Ocean County Prosecutor's Office interferes in township police department operations. The prosecutor's office has asked Superior Court Judge Robert E. Brenner to dismiss the township's lawsuit.

Why it matters

The dispute raises questions about where municipal control over local police ends and county prosecutorial oversight begins. The outcome could shape how Ocean County residents' local government manages police hiring, discipline and internal affairs.

The township has until Dec. 15 to argue why the complaint should not be dismissed, and a hearing is scheduled for Nov. 20 before Judge Brenner. Toms River has requested an adjournment until Dec. 4, and the case remains unresolved.

The players

Ocean County Prosecutor's Office

The county agency responsible for prosecuting criminal cases in Ocean County, New Jersey, which asserts oversight authority over the Toms River police department.

Bradley Billhimer

The Ocean County Prosecutor, named in the lawsuit over alleged interference with Toms River police access and operations.

Michael T. Nolan Jr.

First Assistant Ocean County Prosecutor, named in the township's lawsuit alongside Billhimer.

The details

The lawsuit alleges Ocean County Prosecutor Bradley Billhimer and First Assistant Prosecutor Michael T. Nolan Jr. refused to give Toms River Business Administrator Jonathan Salonis access to a police radio and the department's official Facebook page. The township argues the prosecutor's office took over the police internal affairs division in July and has blocked changes to the background questionnaire for police hires, while the prosecutor's office maintains the department falls under county oversight.

Timeline

  1. June: Township filed its initial lawsuit against the prosecutor's office in state Superior Court in Mercer County.

  2. July: The prosecutor's office took over the police internal affairs division.

  3. Late October: The township filed its legal argument against the prosecutor's office.

  4. Nov. 20: Hearing scheduled before Superior Court Judge Robert E. Brenner.

  5. Dec. 4: Requested adjournment date for the case.

Legal Context

The dispute tests how far county prosecutor oversight of municipal police extends under New Jersey's internal affairs framework, a question that determines whether townships keep control over hiring and discipline. Courts resolving similar county-municipal disagreements will shape how much authority local governments retain over their own police departments.

Residents of Toms River may see changes in how their police department recruits, screens and disciplines officers depending on how the court rules on county oversight. The outcome could affect local decisions on police hiring questionnaires and access to department communications.

The takeaway

Local residents should watch the November hearing, since a ruling on dismissal could define how much say Toms River has over its own police department. The case shows how county and municipal authority over policing can be contested in court.

What happens next

A hearing is scheduled for Nov. 20 before Superior Court Judge Robert E. Brenner, and the township has until Dec. 15 to argue against dismissal.

Further reading

For more on how local police are overseen, see Law Enforcement coverage from Toms River.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Asbury Park Press.