Sephora to Open Full Store at Ocean County Mall

The beauty retailer will take over a former On the Border space as the mall's retail mix continues to shift.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Dining Out

Sephora to Open Full Store at Ocean County Mall

Sephora is opening a full-line store in the former On the Border building at Ocean County Mall in Toms River, with an expected opening in the first week of December. The move follows a series of tenant changes at the mall, including the closure of Sears in 2018 and the arrival of LA Fitness in 2020.

Why it matters

The openings and closures reflect an ongoing reshaping of the Ocean County Mall, with stand-alone buildings and new food and fitness tenants replacing legacy anchors. For Toms River residents, the changes signal how the mall's offerings are evolving.

Placer.ai foot-traffic data puts Ocean County Mall at 5.6 million visits over 12 months, a figure that does not include a prior-year comparison. The extraction does not specify the Sephora store's square footage.

The players

Simon Property Group

A large American real estate investment trust that owns and operates shopping malls and outlet centers across the United States.

Sephora

A Paris-based beauty retailer owned by LVMH that operates stores worldwide selling cosmetics, skincare and fragrance.

Chick-fil-A

An Atlanta-based fast-food chain known for chicken sandwiches and drive-through service, operating restaurants across the country.

The details

Simon Property Group tore down the former Sears and built separate stand-alone buildings on the site after Sears closed in April 2018. Sephora previously operated a smaller counter inside JCPenney before the new full-line store was announced.

Timeline

  1. April 8, 2018: Sears closed at Ocean County Mall.

  2. January 2020: LA Fitness opened at the mall.

  3. November 2022: On the Border opened, later closing in 2025.

  4. May 2025: Bahama Breeze closed.

  5. First week of December: Sephora expected to open.

Dining and Retail Shifts

The mall's redevelopment after the 2018 Sears closure has produced stand-alone buildings that now host food, fitness and beauty tenants instead of a single anchor. Chick-fil-A's approved drive-through plan and Honeygrow's sixth New Jersey location, which opened in December 2023 as its 40th overall, fit that pattern of smaller, single-tenant restaurant formats.

Toms River shoppers will gain a full-line Sephora option inside the mall without leaving Ocean County. The approved Chick-fil-A drive-through and planned Hooper Avenue pad sites could change parking and traffic patterns near the mall.

The takeaway

Watch the Hooper Avenue corridor as new pad sites and the Chick-fil-A drive-through take shape, since these projects will affect how residents reach the mall and nearby restaurants.

What happens next

Sephora is expected to open the first week of December, and the Ocean County Mall plans three new pad sites along Hooper Avenue.

Further reading

For more on the restaurant scene reshaping the area, explore Dining Out coverage in Toms River.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Shore News Network.