Court Largely Denies D.R. Horton Dismissal Bid

A North Carolina Business Court ruling lets a challenge to a 1% transfer fee covenant on a residential development proceed.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Apartments

Court Largely Denies D.R. Horton Dismissal Bid

North Carolina Business Court largely denied D.R. Horton's motion to dismiss a lawsuit challenging a long-running real estate covenant. The plaintiff, acting as trustee for fee beneficiaries, alleges the homebuilder sold newly built homes in the development without paying a 1% transfer fee.

Why it matters

The ruling allows the dispute over whether the covenant remains enforceable to move forward, with the court ordering additional parties joined to the case. The outcome could affect how transfer fee covenants recorded before North Carolina's 2010 statutory ban are treated for current property owners.

The ruling is a 27-page order on a motion to dismiss, not a merits decision. The covenant's 1% fee runs for 99 years, and the court has not yet determined whether it remains valid.

The players

D.R. Horton Inc.

D.R. Horton is one of the largest homebuilders in the United States, publicly traded and headquartered in Texas, and is the defendant in this suit.

The details

The developer argued the covenant was unenforceable under statutes banning private transfer fee covenants, common-law real covenant requirements, and prior termination by the declarants. The court declined to dismiss on horizontal privity and 'touch and concern' grounds because the factual record is not yet sufficiently developed, and it held the complaint alleged a concrete, ongoing legal dispute.

Timeline

  1. July 1, 2010: North Carolina's statutory ban on private transfer fee covenants took effect.

  2. 2010: The declaration was recorded against the residential development.

  3. 2012: A document purporting to terminate the declaration was executed.

  4. 2026: The Business Court issued its ruling (2026 NCBC 56).

Legal Backdrop

North Carolina's 2010 statute banning private transfer fee covenants, effective July 1, 2010, expressly declined to validate older covenants like the one at issue. This case tests how those grandfathered-era covenants are treated in practice for homebuyers in the state.

If you are buying a home in a North Carolina development with a recorded transfer fee covenant, the fee could apply to your purchase depending on how the court rules. Check the recorded declarations for your property before you close.

The takeaway

Transfer fee covenants recorded before North Carolina's 2010 ban may still be contested, so buyers should review recorded declarations for any fee obligations before purchasing. Pending rulings like this one will clarify how those older covenants are handled.

Further reading

For more on housing rules and property costs, explore Apartments coverage across the state.

Source note: This article includes information reported by North Carolina Lawyers Weekly.