Court Revives Homeowners' Driveway Dispute With Association

North Carolina's appeals court sent a Forge Creek driveway fight over architectural approval back to trial for a factfinder to decide.

Updated on Nov. 15, 2026 in Construction

Court Revives Homeowners' Driveway Dispute With Association

Live Poll

Do you think homeowners associations generally enforce their rules fairly toward residents?

The North Carolina Court of Appeals revived a dispute between a Forge Creek homeowner couple and their homeowners association over a driveway built wider than the approved plan. The court held the homeowners violated the governing covenants but ruled the matter must be resolved by a factfinder at trial, and it vacated a preliminary injunction against enforcement of association fines.

Why it matters

The ruling shows that homeowners associations can enforce architectural approvals, but the scope of those restrictions may still be contested in court. For residents of North Carolina, it underscores how covenant conditions on home improvements can lead to fines and litigation when work departs from approved plans.

The homeowners built the driveway roughly one foot wider on each side than the committee's approved dimensions, which limited width to the outside foundation corner of the house. The Court of Appeals sent the question of the overage back to trial, leaving the final resolution of the fines unresolved.

The players

Forge Creek at Flowers Plantation Homeowners Association Inc.

The homeowners association for the Forge Creek subdivision in Johnston County, which enforces the community's covenants and architectural review rules.

North Carolina Court of Appeals

The state's intermediate appellate court, which reviews trial court rulings and issued the decision reviving the driveway dispute.

The details

The Forge Creek homeowners sought permission to widen their driveway, and the Architectural Review Committee approved the expansion only on conditions that barred encroachment into the front entrance walkway. After the homeowners built beyond the approved dimensions, the association imposed fines and demanded compliance. A trial court first issued a preliminary injunction blocking the fines and later granted summary judgment to the homeowners, but the appeals court reversed course on the covenant question and vacated the injunction.

Timeline

  1. Nov. 15, 2026: The North Carolina Court of Appeals revived the dispute and remanded it for trial.

Legal Context

The appeals court vacated the preliminary injunction for failing to address the bond requirement under North Carolina's Rule 65(c), a procedural safeguard that applies beyond this case. The decision places a neighborhood covenant fight within the same framework that governs injunctions in other civil disputes statewide.

Homeowners in covenant-governed communities should review architectural approval conditions before building, since exceeding approved dimensions can trigger fines. Residents facing similar disputes may need to address procedural requirements such as injunction bonds early in litigation.

The takeaway

Homeowners who plan improvements should obtain written approval that matches exactly what they build, because deviations can lead to fines and years of litigation. Confirm the approved dimensions before construction begins.

Further reading

For related coverage, explore Construction news and analysis.

Source note: This article includes information reported by North Carolina Lawyers Weekly.

Live Poll

Do you think homeowners associations generally enforce their rules fairly toward residents?