State Seeks Supreme Court Review of Jones Exoneration

Connecticut prosecutors plan to appeal the 2nd Circuit's decision upholding the exoneration of Maleek Jones, who spent over 30 years imprisoned for a 1992 New Haven murder.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Crime

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain stone civic building facade with a single flagpole against a pale grey sky, evoking institutional legal weight.
Connecticut prosecutors said Wednesday they will ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the appellate decision upholding the exoneration of Maleek Jones, who spent over 30 years imprisoned for a 1992 New Haven murder. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The state's attorney's office said it intends to appeal the exoneration of Maleek Jones to the U.S. Supreme Court after the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld U.S. District Court Judge Janet Hall's 2023 decision. Senior Assistant State's Attorney Jo Anne Sulik communicated the plan to Judge Hall at a video status conference on Wednesday afternoon.

Why it matters

The appeal would extend a long-running legal challenge to a conviction that Judge Hall overturned after finding the defense failed to adequately represent Jones. The outcome could determine whether the exoneration stands and affects how similar post-conviction claims are weighed in New Haven cases.

The state plans to file a motion to stay the appellate mandate while it petitions the U.S. Supreme Court, after the 2nd Circuit upheld Judge Hall's exoneration of Jones on November 10, 2026. Whether the Supreme Court will take up the matter remains unknown.

The players

Maleek Jones

Jones was exonerated after more than 30 years in prison for a 1992 New Haven murder, a case that has drawn attention to the reliability of the original trial defense.

Janet Hall

Judge Janet Hall is the U.S. District Court judge who overturned Jones's conviction in 2023 and whose ruling the appeals court has now upheld.

Jo Anne Sulik

Jo Anne Sulik is a senior assistant state's attorney who announced the state's intention to appeal at the video status conference.

The details

Judge Hall overturned Jones's conviction after finding his public defender failed to contact the sole independent witness and that the trial court improperly excluded testimony from a person to whom another shooter had confessed. The state contends the conviction is valid, according to Jones's account of its position.

Timeline

  1. 1992: Murder of Eddie Harp occurs in New Haven.

  2. 2023: Judge Hall issues the original exoneration decision.

  3. November 10, 2026: The 2nd Circuit upholds Hall's decision by a 2-1 majority.

  4. Wednesday, November 18, 2026: The state announces its intent to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Legal Context

In 2015 the 2nd Circuit upheld the exoneration of Scott Lewis and the state did not appeal further, whereas in the Jones case prosecutors are pursuing review at the U.S. Supreme Court. The contrast highlights how differently the state has approached comparable wrongful-conviction rulings in this jurisdiction.

The appeal means the Jones exoneration remains unsettled while the state seeks Supreme Court review, so the outcome could take additional time to resolve. Residents following post-conviction cases in New Haven should watch for any ruling on the state's motion to stay the mandate.

The takeaway

Wrongful-conviction rulings can remain contested for years after a court acts, and the Jones case shows how an exoneration may still depend on appellate review. Readers tracking the case should follow the state's filings and any Supreme Court decision on whether to hear it.

Further reading

For more on how these cases move through the system, see Criminal Justice coverage from New Haven.

Source note: This article includes information reported by New Haven Indy.