New Haven Sues Insurer Over $30.5M Settlement

The city says Westport Insurance Corporation should cover part of the wrongful conviction payout it refuses to pay.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Crime

New Haven Sues Insurer Over $30.5M Settlement

Live Poll

Do you trust your local government to manage taxpayer money responsibly?

New Haven filed a breach of contract lawsuit in federal court against Westport Insurance Corporation, a Missouri-based insurer, after the company refused to fully cover a $30.5 million wrongful conviction settlement. The city's insurance was to cover the first $5 million plus attorney costs, leaving New Haven responsible for the remaining $25.5 million.

Why it matters

Westport declined full indemnification because the underlying lawsuits did not involve bodily injury or personal injury, a dispute that could shape how municipalities recover costs from insurers in wrongful conviction cases. For New Haven residents, the disputed sum is being carried by taxpayers, with the Board of Alders voting to borrow $27 million to cover the gap.

New Haven filed the breach of contract suit in federal court on Friday, and the court has not yet issued a ruling. The Board of Alders authorized $27 million in borrowing, but the outcome of the insurance dispute remains unresolved.

The players

Westport Insurance Corporation

Westport Insurance Corporation is a Missouri-based insurer that the city of New Haven is suing for refusing to fully indemnify a wrongful conviction settlement.

The details

Vernon Horn and Marquis Jackson were convicted of murder and armed robbery in the 1999 shooting death of Caprice Hardy at a New Haven deli and were exonerated in 2018 after re-investigation. Horn served 17 years and Jackson served 19 years in prison, and the state had previously awarded them $4.8 million and $5.3 million for their wrongful convictions.

Timeline

  1. 1999: Caprice Hardy was shot and killed at a New Haven deli.

  2. 2018: Horn and Jackson were exonerated after re-investigation.

  3. August 2026: The mayor announced a $15.25 million payment to each man.

  4. October 2026: The Board of Alders voted to borrow $27 million.

  5. November 13, 2026: New Haven filed its federal lawsuit against Westport Insurance.

Legal Context

Cities across the country increasingly face coverage disputes with insurers over wrongful conviction payouts, and New Haven's suit tests whether policies without explicit bodily injury language can shield insurers from paying. The outcome could influence how municipalities budget for exonerations in future cases.

New Haven residents will ultimately bear the cost of the disputed $25.5 million through municipal borrowing, with the bond authorization projected to cost as much as $40.5 million by July 2047. The federal lawsuit's outcome will determine how much of that burden the city can shift to its insurer.

The takeaway

The case highlights that municipal insurance policies may not cover wrongful conviction settlements when claims lack explicit bodily or personal injury language. Cities should review their coverage terms carefully before exonerations generate costly payouts.

Further reading

Explore more in Criminal Justice coverage for New Haven.

Source note: This article includes information reported by New Haven Register.

Live Poll

Do you trust your local government to manage taxpayer money responsibly?