Panel Backs Up to $17.5M Bond for Carmon Settlement
New Haven's finance committee recommended borrowing to cover a $16.5 million settlement with Adam Carmon, who was exonerated after 29 years in prison.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Crime

The New Haven aldermanic finance committee recommended bonding up to $17.5 million to cover a $16.5 million settlement with Adam Carmon, who was convicted in 1995 of murdering 7-month-old Danielle Taft. The Board of Alders is scheduled to vote on the bond on Dec. 7.
Why it matters
The city was not insured for wrongful convictions at the time, so New Haven must pay the award from its own borrowing. Defense attorneys said police and prosecutors withheld 40 pieces of evidence from Carmon's lawyers during his initial trial.
The Board of Alders approved $27 million in borrowing last month for a separate settlement with two men, and the Carmon bond now awaits a full vote on Dec. 7. The state separately awarded Carmon $7.9 million for his wrongful conviction.
The players
Adam Carmon
Carmon was exonerated in 2022 after serving 29 years of an 85-year sentence for a 1995 murder conviction that was later undermined.
New Haven Board of Alders
The Board of Alders is New Haven's legislative body, which approved $27 million in separate settlement borrowing last month and will vote on the Carmon bond.
The details
Carmon was convicted in 1995 of murdering Danielle Taft, a 7-month-old killed in a 1994 shooting on Orchard Street, and served 29 years of an 85-year sentence. He was exonerated in 2022 and all charges were dropped during a 2023 retrial, after new forensic evidence undermined the verdict.
Timeline
Feb. 3, 1994: Shooting on Orchard Street kills Danielle Taft.
1995: Carmon is convicted of murder.
2022: Carmon is exonerated.
2023: All charges are dropped during retrial.
Dec. 7, 2026: Full Board of Alders scheduled to vote on the bond.
Legal Context
Cities that lack insurance for wrongful convictions must fund settlements from public borrowing, as New Haven is doing with the Carmon award. The $27 million separate settlement approved last month shows the cost is accumulating across multiple cases.
New Haven residents will carry the cost of the settlement through city debt, with an estimated $8.75 million in interest on top of the $16.5 million award. The bond is expected to be paid off in 2047.
The takeaway
Wrongful-conviction payouts can become long-term municipal debt when cities lack insurance, and the interest can add substantially to the original award. Residents can follow the Dec. 7 Board of Alders vote to see how the borrowing is finalized.
What happens next
The full Board of Alders is scheduled to vote on the up-to-$17.5 million bond on Dec. 7, 2026.
Further reading
For more on how these cases move through the courts, see Criminal Justice coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by New Haven Register.






