Public Defender Appeals $26,000 Contempt Fine
San Francisco Public Defender Mano Raju is challenging a court ruling that fined his office for limiting its caseload.
Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Crime

Live Poll
Should governments spend more to fund public defenders for people who cannot afford lawyers?
San Francisco Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman ruled the Public Defender's Office must pay $1,000 for each of 26 acts of contempt, a total of $26,000. Raju presented oral arguments in California's 1st District Court of Appeal on Thursday, and the fine has been stayed pending the outcome of the appeal.
Why it matters
The dispute centers on whether a public defender's office can decline court-assigned felony cases when staffing is stretched, a question that affects defendants' access to counsel in San Francisco. Public defenders from 36 California counties issued a joint statement supporting Raju ahead of his hearing, signaling statewide interest in the outcome.
The $26,000 fine has been stayed while Raju appeals the contempt ruling in California's 1st District Court of Appeal, which heard oral arguments on Thursday, November 20, 2026. A decision is expected within 90 days, and the outcome will determine whether the penalty stands.
The players
Mano Raju
Mano Raju is the San Francisco Public Defender whose office was fined for refusing court-assigned felony cases.
San Francisco Public Defender's Office
The San Francisco Public Defender's Office provides legal representation to criminal defendants who cannot afford private counsel.
The details
Raju stopped accepting every felony case assigned by the court in May 2025, citing an overworked staff, a lack of funding, and rising felony filings from the District Attorney's Office. Judge Dorfman ruled the office had enough attorneys to take on the caseload, while counsel Kory DeClark argued the court did not gather sufficient caseload data before reaching that conclusion.
Timeline
May 2025: Raju stopped accepting every court-assigned case.
Thursday, November 20, 2026: Raju and counsel presented oral arguments in the 1st District Court of Appeal.
Within 90 days of November 2026: The appeals court is expected to issue a ruling.
Legal Context
The appeal turns on a California Penal Code provision requiring alternative counsel when a public defender's office cannot take a case. The ruling could clarify how far county public defenders can go in declining assigned caseloads statewide.
Residents facing felony charges in San Francisco could see delays or changes in who represents them if the Public Defender's Office continues to limit its caseload. The appeal's outcome will determine whether the office must accept cases it currently declines.
The takeaway
Court rulings on public defender caseloads can shape how quickly and by whom criminal defendants receive representation. Readers following local justice issues should watch for the appellate decision expected in early 2027.
What happens next
The California 1st District Court of Appeal is expected to issue its ruling within 90 days of November 2026.
Further reading
Explore more on Criminal Justice coverage in San Francisco.
Source note: This article includes information reported by SFist - San Francisco News, Restaurants, Events, & Sports.
Live Poll
Should governments spend more to fund public defenders for people who cannot afford lawyers?






