Dorsey Proposes Moving Hall of Justice

The San Francisco supervisor wants a courthouse site closer to other government buildings as the aging Bryant Street facility faces repeated problems.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Crime

Weathered mid-century concrete civic building with rust-streaked seams and a steel bracing frame across an empty wet plaza under overcast skies.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Matt Dorsey proposed relocating the aging Hall of Justice at 850 Bryant St. closer to other government buildings, citing seismic and water damage. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should San Francisco spend heavily to replace its aging Hall of Justice?

Supervisor Matt Dorsey proposed relocating the San Francisco Hall of Justice to a site closer to other government buildings at a Budget and Finance Committee meeting. The Superior Court of California confirmed the courthouse is on the state's shortlist for funding.

Why it matters

The Hall of Justice at 850 Bryant St. has been rated high-risk for seismic safety and has suffered structural and water damage, making its future a concern for thousands of people who use the building each year. A move would affect how defendants, attorneys, judges and law enforcement officials in San Francisco access the courts.

The 2026 state budget names the new San Francisco Hall of Justice among five courthouse projects the Legislature may fund through the 2027 state budget, and the city's capital plan allocates $367 million in Certificates of Participation for the exit program between fiscal 2027 and fiscal 2032. Whether the Legislature will approve funding and which site will be chosen remain unresolved.

The players

Matt Dorsey

Dorsey is a San Francisco Board of Supervisors member who made the relocation proposal at the Budget and Finance Committee.

Superior Court of California

The Superior Court of California is the trial court system that confirmed the Hall of Justice is on the state's shortlist for funding.

Judicial Council of California

The Judicial Council of California is the policymaking body for the state court system that gave the building its high-risk seismic rating and plans to seek funding for a new courthouse.

The details

The Judicial Council of California gave the building a high-risk seismic rating in 2017, and sewage leaked through the district attorney's office ceiling that same year, prompting the office to move out. The last jail facility in the Hall of Justice closed in 2020, and rainwater from Wednesday's storms poured through the ceilings. Architect Lisa Follman presented several Mid-Market sites, including 50 United Nations Plaza, 1455 Market St., Hotel Whitcomb and San Francisco Centre, as possible courthouse locations.

Timeline

  1. 2008: Six departments began leaving the Hall of Justice.

  2. 2017: The Judicial Council gave the building a high-risk seismic rating.

  3. 2020: The last jail facility in the Hall of Justice closed.

  4. 2024: The Superior Court announced it would seek courthouse funding.

  5. November 18, 2026: Storm rainwater leaked through the ceilings, and Dorsey made his proposal at a committee meeting.

Legal Context

The Hall of Justice is one of five courthouse projects named in the 2026 state budget that the Legislature may fund through the 2027 state budget. Its potential relocation reflects a broader effort by the San Francisco court system to replace a facility that has been considered unsafe for nearly a decade.

Anyone who serves on a jury, attends a hearing or appears as a defendant, witness or attorney at the Hall of Justice may see changes in where and how court business is conducted if a relocation moves forward. The building's ongoing water and structural problems mean that court access could be disrupted in the meantime.

The takeaway

Aging public buildings can quietly become safety problems long before a replacement is funded, so the timing of state appropriations will largely determine when San Francisco's courts move. Residents who rely on the courthouse should watch the 2027 state budget for a decision.

Further reading

For more on how the courts operate, explore the Criminal Justice coverage on Wisevoter.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The San Francisco Standard.

Live Poll

Should San Francisco spend heavily to replace its aging Hall of Justice?