Judge Holds Public Defender in Contempt

A San Francisco superior court judge found Public Defender Manu Raju in contempt for refusing new cases, and his office is appealing the ruling.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Crime

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a monumental civic courthouse facade in navy and cream with a muted red accent, evoking institutional weight in a judicial dispute.
San Francisco Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman held Public Defender Manu Raju in contempt for refusing new cases, and his office is appealing the $26,000 fine. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman held San Francisco Public Defender Manu Raju in contempt of court for refusing to accept new cases on behalf of his office. Raju had been ordered in March to pay a $26,000 fine, and the public defender's office is appealing the contempt ruling in appellate court.

Why it matters

The ruling pits a court's authority to assign cases against a public defender's claim that its caseload prevents it from meeting its ethical obligations to clients. How the appellate court resolves the dispute could affect how defense caseloads are managed across San Francisco's criminal courts.

Judge Harry Dorfman ordered Manu Raju to pay a $26,000 fine in March after finding him in contempt for refusing new cases, and the public defender's office is appealing. Attorneys for the office are scheduled to appear in appellate court on Thursday, and the court will have 90 days to decide the matter.

The players

Manu Raju

Manu Raju is the San Francisco Public Defender, the city official responsible for providing legal representation to people who cannot afford an attorney.

Harry Dorfman

Harry Dorfman is a San Francisco Superior Court judge who presides over criminal matters and is responsible for assigning cases to the public defender's office.

The details

The public defender's office argues it has too many cases to meet its ethical obligations to clients, while Judge Dorfman cited 26 specific cases the office should accept. The dispute centers on whether the court can compel the office to take on additional matters despite its existing caseload.

Timeline

  1. March 2026: Manu Raju was ordered to pay a $26,000 fine for failing to accept new cases.

  2. November 19, 2026: Attorneys for the public defender's office were scheduled to argue the appeal in appellate court.

  3. 90 days after arguments: The appellate court is expected to issue its decision.

Legal Context

The dispute tests how far courts can go in compelling public defender offices to accept additional cases when they claim caseloads already exceed what ethical representation allows. The appellate ruling will help define the limits of judicial authority over defense workloads in San Francisco's criminal courts.

Residents charged with crimes in San Francisco could see delays in representation if the public defender's office continues to refuse new cases during the appeal. The outcome may also affect how quickly defendants are assigned counsel in local criminal courts.

The takeaway

Caseload limits and court orders now collide in San Francisco's criminal courts, and the appellate decision will show which obligation takes priority. Residents following local criminal cases should watch for that ruling in the coming months.

What happens next

The appellate court is expected to issue its decision within 90 days after Thursday's arguments.

Further reading

For related coverage of how court cases move through the system, see Criminal Justice reporting.

Source note: This article includes information reported by KALW.