Judge Reassigns Police Bias Investigations to New Investigator

A federal monitor found AZ Truth Finder's appointment as independent investigator deficient in the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office reform case.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Crime

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain stone courthouse facade against a pale desert horizon, evoking federal court oversight of police investigations in Arizona.
U.S. District Judge G. Murray Snow reassigned all internal affairs investigations of the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office from AZ Truth Finder to attorney Shaneeda Jaffer after a federal monitor found the firm's appointment deficient. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust local police oversight investigators to be fair and independent?

U.S. District Judge G. Murray Snow reassigned all internal affairs investigations previously assigned to AZ Truth Finder to attorney Shaneeda Jaffer. The federal monitor determined the process of AZ Truth Finder's appointment was deficient and now considers the firm unqualified.

Why it matters

The change affects oversight of internal affairs investigations within the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office, a central part of the court-supervised bias reform effort in Arizona. It underscores how closely the court is scrutinizing who is selected to independently review allegations against deputies.

The federal monitor's finding that AZ Truth Finder is unqualified and Judge Snow's order reassigning all of its investigations to Jaffer are the current procedural status. The specific deficiencies cited by the monitor and any further court action remain unspecified in the extraction.

The players

Maricopa County Sheriff's Office

The Arizona county law enforcement agency whose internal affairs process is subject to the court-supervised bias reform case.

AZ Truth Finder

The firm that was serving as independent internal affairs investigator before the federal monitor found its appointment deficient.

G. Murray Snow

The U.S. District Judge overseeing the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office bias reform case who ordered the reassignment.

Shaneeda Jaffer

A Cleveland-based attorney with the firm Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan and Aronoff who previously conducted similar investigations in the Northern District of California.

Jerry Sheridan

The Maricopa County sheriff who said AZ Truth Finder was the only respondent to the county's request for proposal that met requirements.

The details

Snow issued the order Tuesday, reassigning investigations that had been handled by AZ Truth Finder to Jaffer, a Cleveland-based attorney who first took on the role in May 2025. Maricopa County had contracted with AZ Truth Finder and objected to Jaffer's appointment, but Snow rejected those objections in two specific investigations.

Timeline

  1. May 2025: Snow first appointed Jaffer as independent investigator.

  2. October: Snow unsealed a report linking AZ Truth Finder's founder to two right-wing organizations.

  3. Tuesday, November 17: Snow issued the order reassigning investigations to Jaffer.

Legal Context

The reassignment is a development in the federal court-supervised bias reform case against the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office, where the judge is actively policing the independence of internal affairs investigators. Judge Snow's rejection of county objections in two investigations shows the court is willing to override local contracting choices to enforce those conditions.

Residents of Maricopa County may see changes in how complaints against sheriff's deputies are investigated, since the independent investigator handling those cases has changed. The reassignment means the court-appointed reviewer for these internal affairs matters is now Jaffer rather than AZ Truth Finder.

The takeaway

Court oversight of police internal investigations can shift quickly when an appointed reviewer is found unqualified, and the selection process itself is subject to judicial review. Readers following local policing reform should watch how the monitor's findings are addressed in future filings.

Further reading

Explore more Law Enforcement coverage from across Arizona.

Live Poll

Do you trust local police oversight investigators to be fair and independent?