Maricopa Prosecutor Declines Charges in Noncitizen Voting Case
Eight noncitizens who cast ballots in Maricopa County will not face prosecution after investigators found they were in the country legally.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Immigration

Live Poll
Do you trust your county's election system to keep non-citizens off the voter rolls?
Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell declined to prosecute eight noncitizens who voted, after investigators confirmed 52 of 60 flagged voters were U.S. citizens. The probe followed a state Motor Vehicle Division registration glitch dating to 2004 that was discovered in 2024.
Why it matters
The decision shows how a state registration system error can place legally present residents on voter rolls and lead to ballots being cast. For Arizona readers, it bears on how the state and counties verify voter eligibility and correct systemic data problems.
Maricopa County Recorder's Office ran more than 60,000 registered voters through the federal SAVE database, which flagged 207 names for review. Investigators confirmed that 60 flagged individuals voted at least once, with eight noncitizens casting 16 ballots combined from 2012 to 2025, never more than three in any single election.
The players
Rachel Mitchell
Maricopa County Attorney who declined to prosecute the eight noncitizens who voted, citing the registration system error as the cause in seven cases.
Justin Heap
Maricopa County Recorder whose office ran voter records through the federal SAVE database and referred the 207 flagged names to the county attorney.
Maricopa County Attorney's Office
The county prosecutor's office that investigated the flagged voters and made the decision not to bring charges.
The details
Seven of the eight cases involved people who believed receiving a ballot meant they were permitted to vote. Mitchell said the state registration system error was responsible for seven of the eight cases, while the eighth person checked the noncitizen box on a registration form and still received a ballot.
Timeline
2004: State Motor Vehicle Division registration glitch dates back.
2012 to 2025: Eight noncitizens cast 16 ballots combined.
2024: Registration system glitch discovered.
March: Recorder Justin Heap referred 207 flagged names to the county attorney.
September: 52 of 60 voters confirmed as U.S. citizens.
Political Context
Arizona's voter-verification effort relies on the federal SAVE database to check citizenship against registration records. The county's findings that most flagged voters were citizens raise questions about whether automated flags overstate the scale of noncitizen voting.
For Arizona voters, the case shows that a registration error can place eligible residents on voter rolls without their knowledge. Residents who believe their records are incorrect can check their registration status with county recorders.
The takeaway
Registration systems need regular audits because errors can affect legally present residents who believed they were allowed to vote. Checking voter records against accurate citizenship data helps prevent these cases from arising in the first place.
Further reading
For related coverage of how states handle noncitizen voter cases, see Immigration in Arizona politics.
Source note: This article includes information reported by KTAR.
Live Poll
Do you trust your county's election system to keep non-citizens off the voter rolls?






