Judge Denies Dismissal in Goodyear Child Murder Case
A judge in Goodyear, Arizona, has rejected a motion to dismiss the murder case against a couple accused of killing their seven-year-old daughter in 2017.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Judge Patricia Starr denied a motion to dismiss the murder case against a Goodyear couple accused of killing their daughter in 2017, clearing the way for a retrial. The earlier trial ended in a mistrial in April 2026 after Goodyear police were found to have mishandled key evidence.
Why it matters
The ruling means the prosecution can proceed after a mistrial caused by evidence-handling failures by the Goodyear Police Department, which the judge found knew of records-system problems before trial but did not disclose them. For Goodyear residents, the case underscores how police record-keeping failures can derail serious criminal prosecutions.
The couple faces a charge of first-degree murder and the judge has denied their motion to dismiss, allowing the case to proceed to retrial. The retrial is set for April 2027, though that date could change.
The players
Goodyear Police Department
The Goodyear Police Department is the municipal law enforcement agency serving the city of Goodyear, Arizona, and handled the evidence at the center of the case.
Judge Patricia Starr
Judge Patricia Starr presides over the case and ruled both on the mistrial and on the motion to dismiss.
The details
Judge Patricia Starr found that Goodyear police mishandled key evidence and could not prove chain of custody going back years, and ruled that the problems with the department's records system were not disclosed. She found no prosecutorial misconduct, placing responsibility on the police department rather than prosecutors, and said the defense now has access to the previously withheld information.
Timeline
2017: Daughter killed; the couple is accused of the murder.
September 2025: First trial began.
April 2026: Judge Starr declared a mistrial.
November 2026: Judge Starr denied the motion to dismiss.
April 2027: Retrial scheduled.
Legal Context
This ruling follows the April 2026 mistrial in the same case, which was triggered by evidence-handling failures that the judge found the Goodyear Police Department knew about before trial. Allowing retrial after the disclosure reflects how courts often remedy police misconduct without dismissing charges when prosecutors themselves are found blameless.
For residents of Goodyear, the case highlights how gaps in police evidence management can delay justice for victims and their families. The retrial will proceed with the defense holding information that was previously withheld.
The takeaway
Sound evidence management is central to prosecutions, and records-system failures can force mistrials even when prosecutors are not at fault. Readers following the case should watch for changes to the April 2027 retrial date.
What happens next
The retrial is scheduled for April 2027, though that date could change.
Further reading
Explore more criminal justice coverage for related court and prosecution developments.
Source note: This article includes information reported by abc15 Arizona.






