Jack Smith Moves to Dismiss Blackburn Lawsuit

Smith argues a Tennessee court lacks jurisdiction over his Arctic Frost investigation role and that Blackburn lacks standing.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Law

Jack Smith Moves to Dismiss Blackburn Lawsuit

Special counsel Jack Smith filed a motion to dismiss Sen. Marsha Blackburn's lawsuit in Nashville, Tennessee, on Thursday, November 20, 2026. Blackburn sued in late September, asking the court to declare Smith unlawfully appointed over the Arctic Frost investigation.

Why it matters

The motion asks whether a federal court in Tennessee can hear a challenge to the appointment of a special counsel who, Smith's filing says, was validly appointed. The outcome could shape how lawmakers may challenge investigators whose work touches them directly.

Smith's motion argues the court lacks personal jurisdiction over him and that venue is improper, while also contending Blackburn lacks standing to seek the relief she requests. The case has been assigned to U.S. District Judge Douglas R. Cole after active district judges recused themselves.

The players

Jack Smith

Jack Smith is the former special counsel who led federal investigations into Donald Trump, and whose appointment has been challenged in court.

Marsha Blackburn

Marsha Blackburn is a Republican U.S. senator from Tennessee who has been an outspoken supporter of Donald Trump.

New Civil Liberties Alliance

The New Civil Liberties Alliance is a nonprofit public-interest law firm that litigates constitutional challenges, including against federal officials.

The details

Blackburn alleges Smith conspired to injure her because of her support for Donald Trump, including by subpoenaing her toll records during the Jan. 6 investigation. Smith's filing says toll records contain routing information rather than call content, and his counsel has publicly responded to claims that he tapped or spied on lawmakers' phones.

Timeline

  1. Late September 2025: Blackburn filed the lawsuit against Smith.

  2. 2024: Judge Aileen Cannon ruled Smith was unlawfully appointed when she dismissed Trump's Mar-a-Lago prosecution.

  3. Thursday, November 20, 2026: Smith filed his motion to dismiss in Nashville.

Legal Context

The lawsuit echoes Judge Aileen Cannon's 2024 ruling that Smith was unlawfully appointed when she threw out Trump's Mar-a-Lago prosecution. Smith's filing now argues he was validly appointed, setting up a second judicial test of the same question.

The ruling on jurisdiction and standing will determine whether challenges to federal special counsel appointments can proceed in courts outside Washington. Readers following federal investigations should watch whether the case moves forward or is dismissed on procedural grounds.

The takeaway

A procedural ruling on venue and standing may decide this case before the constitutional question of Smith's appointment is ever reached. Readers should expect the jurisdictional fight to come first.

Further reading

For more on how courts handle challenges to federal prosecutors, see the Law section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Law & Crime.