Fifth Circuit Rules House Proxy Voting Unconstitutional
The full New Orleans-based appeals court found remote voting by House members violated the Constitution's Quorum Clause.
Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should members of Congress have to be physically present to vote on laws?
The en banc Fifth Circuit in New Orleans ruled that the U.S. House of Representatives unconstitutionally passed a spending package during the Covid-19 pandemic, when members cast votes by proxy. Judge Cory Wilson wrote the majority opinion, which relies on the Constitution's Quorum Clause and holds that Members of Congress must be present for quorum purposes.
Why it matters
The ruling could open the door to new legal challenges against some laws enacted during former President Joe Biden's administration. It is a significant constitutional interpretation of how Congress may conduct its votes and establish a quorum.
The full Fifth Circuit evaluated the text, context, original understanding, and historical application of the Quorum Clause before ruling that remote voting by House members violated the Constitution. The extraction does not indicate the vote counts on the spending package or whether the ruling will be appealed.
The players
U.S. House of Representatives
The lower chamber of Congress, whose remote proxy voting practice was ruled unconstitutional by the Fifth Circuit.
Judge Cory Wilson
A federal appellate judge on the Fifth Circuit who wrote the majority opinion holding that proxy voting violates the Constitution.
The details
The en banc court found that members voted on a spending package by proxy during the Covid-19 pandemic and that this practice violated the Quorum Clause. The majority opinion, written by Judge Cory Wilson, holds that Members of Congress must be physically present for quorum purposes.
Timeline
Covid-19 pandemic: the spending package was passed with proxy voting.
November 21, 2026: the Fifth Circuit en banc ruling was published.
Political Context
The ruling rests on the Constitution's Quorum Clause, which the majority read to require that Members of Congress be present for quorum purposes. The decision reopens constitutional scrutiny of legislation passed under remote voting rules adopted during the pandemic.
Laws passed during the Biden administration that relied on proxy votes may now face new constitutional challenges in court. Citizens affected by those laws should watch for litigation that could alter or invalidate them.
The takeaway
The ruling makes physical presence in Congress a constitutional question, not just a procedural one. Readers tracking federal legislation should note that votes cast by proxy may now be legally vulnerable.
Further reading
For related coverage of court challenges to federal legislation, see the Law section.
Live Poll
Should members of Congress have to be physically present to vote on laws?






