Hagerty Files Disbarment Complaint Against Jack Smith

Senator Bill Hagerty asked Tennessee regulators to revoke the former special counsel's law license over efforts to obtain lawmakers' phone records.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Legislative Policy

Hagerty Files Disbarment Complaint Against Jack Smith

Live Poll

Should politicians be allowed to file complaints to revoke opponents' law licenses?

Sen. Bill Hagerty filed a disbarment complaint against Jack Smith with the Tennessee Board of Professional Responsibility, asking that Smith's law license be revoked. Smith's attorneys called the complaint meritless and said it retaliates against his free speech.

Why it matters

The complaint ties a disciplinary challenge to a dispute over nondisclosure orders that barred phone carriers from revealing that GOP lawmakers' call logs had been subpoenaed. Republicans argue those orders violate the Speech or Debate Clause, while Smith's team says the secrecy was meant to keep the investigation from interference.

Hagerty filed the complaint one day after Smith's September 2026 Senate Judiciary testimony. The Tennessee board has not publicly said whether it will act on the complaint.

The players

Bill Hagerty

A Republican U.S. senator from Tennessee who filed the disbarment complaint against Smith.

Jack Smith

A former special counsel whose efforts to obtain lawmakers' phone records are the subject of the complaint.

Board of Professional Responsibility of the Supreme Court of Tennessee

The state body that oversees attorney discipline and received the complaint.

The details

Hagerty asked the board to revoke Smith's law license over efforts to obtain phone records of GOP lawmakers around Jan. 6, 2021. Smith secured a court order barring carriers from disclosing the subpoenas; the records showed who lawmakers contacted but not what they said. In a Nov. 3 letter, Smith called the complaint a retaliatory political stunt, and Sen. Marsha Blackburn has separately sued Smith and the Justice Department.

Timeline

  1. Jan. 6, 2021: Capitol attack; period of lawmakers' phone records sought.

  2. September 2026: Smith testifies before the Senate Judiciary Committee.

  3. Nov. 3, 2026: Smith sends letter to the Tennessee discipline board.

  4. Nov. 13, 2026: Politico reports Smith's response to the complaint.

Legislative Policy Context

Republicans argue the nondisclosure orders violate the Speech or Debate Clause, which Smith's attorneys say protects lawmakers only from forced testimony or criminal penalties over legislative work. The complaint places that constitutional question before a state disciplinary body rather than a federal court.

For attorneys and lawmakers, the outcome could clarify how far discipline complaints can reach investigators who obtain congressional records. The board's response, if any, will indicate whether such complaints move forward.

The takeaway

The case shows how a constitutional dispute over lawmakers' privileges can migrate into state attorney discipline proceedings. Readers tracking congressional oversight should watch whether the Tennessee board acts on the complaint.

Further reading

Explore more on Legislative Policy for context on congressional oversight disputes.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Raw Story.

Live Poll

Should politicians be allowed to file complaints to revoke opponents' law licenses?