Producer Sues Over Sample on Travis Scott Track

Israeli producer Niv Kalisky, known as Early Yellow, alleges he has not received master royalties for a sample used in 'What To Do?'.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Hip-Hop and Rap

Bold flat-color hot pink and black hip-hop poster illustration with a split waveform bisected by a torn halftone circle over a checkerboard field.
Producer Niv Kalisky, known as Early Yellow, filed a lawsuit on November 17 against Travis Scott, Cactus Jack, Sony and others, alleging unpaid master royalties for a sample on 'What To Do?'. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Israeli music producer Niv Kalisky, who goes by Early Yellow, filed a lawsuit on Tuesday, November 17, against Cactus Jack, Sony, Travis Scott, Don Toliver, Sheck Wes and several producers over 'What To Do?' from the 2019 album JACKBOYS. Kalisky says he supplied a sample beat that was mixed into the final recording.

Why it matters

The suit centers on whether a producer who supplied a sample is owed a share of master recording revenue from album sales, streaming and synch licensing. Kalisky alleges that repeated royalty requests and takedown attempts were countered, a dispute that could shape how credits and revenue are handled for sample-based hip-hop tracks.

'What To Do?' peaked at No. 56 on the Billboard Hot 100 and No. 20 on the Hot Rap Songs chart, and JACKBOYS debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200. The lawsuit does not specify a dollar figure for the recording revenue Kalisky seeks.

The players

Cactus Jack Records

Travis Scott's record label, which released the JACKBOYS collective's work and is named as a defendant.

Sony Music / Epic Records

A major global music company whose Epic Records unit is accused of canceling takedown requests and is named as a defendant.

Travis Scott

A Grammy-nominated rapper and the central figure of the JACKBOYS collective, named as a defendant.

The details

Kalisky says he provided a sample beat that was later mixed into the final sound recording of 'What To Do?', on which he is credited as songwriter and additional producer. His lawyers allegedly sent multiple royalty requests to Cactus Jack and Epic Records, and his team submitted takedown requests to Spotify and Apple Music, which Sony allegedly countered with notices to the streamers.

Timeline

  1. 2019: JACKBOYS and 'What To Do?' are released.

  2. Summer 2025: JACKBOYS 2 is released and tops the charts.

  3. Tuesday, November 17, 2026: Kalisky files the lawsuit.

Industry Dynamics

The dispute reflects a recurring tension in hip-hop over whether producers who supply samples or beats share in master recording income, a question that has surfaced in disputes across the genre. The case also tests how labels respond to takedown requests from non-featured contributors once a project has become a commercial hit.

The lawsuit does not change how listeners can access 'What To Do?', which remains available on streaming platforms as of the extraction. Fans can still stream the track, though the dispute could affect whether it stays available in its current form.

The takeaway

Credit and royalty disputes over samples often hinge on paperwork signed years earlier, so contributors to a track may want clear written agreements that address master revenue, not just songwriting credit.

Further reading

Explore more coverage in the Hip-Hop and Rap section.