Appeals Court Revives Late Tax Petition Case

The Fourth Circuit held that the 90-day deadline for challenging a tax deficiency is not jurisdictional, so a late filing can still be heard by the Tax Court.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Taxes

Appeals Court Revives Late Tax Petition Case

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reversed a Tax Court dismissal of a taxpayer's petition challenging tax penalties, which had been dismissed without considering extenuating circumstances. The appellate court ruled on Wednesday, November 18, 2026.

Why it matters

The ruling joins a widening circuit split over whether the Section 6213(a) deadline limits the Tax Court's power, which could affect how other late-filed deficiency petitions are treated across the country. Taxpayers facing missed filing windows may find that courts are increasingly willing to weigh the circumstances of a late petition.

The Section 6213(a) deadline for filing a petition challenging a tax deficiency is 90 days. The Fourth Circuit's holding that this deadline is nonjurisdictional leaves open how the Tax Court will apply it in cases where extenuating circumstances are present.

The players

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit

The federal appellate court covering Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and West Virginia, which reviews decisions from U.S. district courts and certain specialized tribunals.

United States Tax Court

A federal court that hears disputes over tax deficiencies and penalties before taxpayers pay the disputed amounts, and whose decisions are reviewed by the federal courts of appeals.

The details

The Tax Court had dismissed a taxpayer's petition for redetermination of penalties without considering whether extenuating circumstances explained the late filing. The Fourth Circuit held that the 90-day deadline is a claims-processing rule rather than a jurisdictional bar, so the Tax Court retains power to hear the late petition.

Timeline

  1. November 18, 2026: Fourth Circuit issues ruling reversing the Tax Court dismissal.

Legal Context

The Fourth Circuit's decision adds to a split among federal appeals courts over whether Section 6213(a) is jurisdictional, a question that determines whether the Tax Court can hear petitions filed after the 90-day window. The ruling places the Fourth Circuit alongside courts that treat the deadline as a claims-processing rule subject to equitable considerations.

Taxpayers who miss the 90-day window to contest a deficiency may have a better chance of getting a Tax Court hearing if the circumstances of the delay are considered. Anyone who receives a notice of deficiency should track the deadline closely, since the rules still vary by circuit.

The takeaway

Courts are divided on how strictly the 90-day deficiency deadline applies, so taxpayers should act within the window whenever possible rather than rely on a later hearing. Anyone who has received a notice of deficiency should consult a tax professional promptly.

Further reading

For background on filing deadlines and disputes with the IRS, see more Taxes coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.