DOJ Cites Tenth Circuit Ruling in Blum Tax Case

The Justice Department notified the First Circuit of a Tenth Circuit decision in Blum v. Commissioner, a dispute over a $16 million tax matter.

Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Taxes

DOJ Cites Tenth Circuit Ruling in Blum Tax Case

The Justice Department filed notice with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit on Tuesday citing the Tenth Circuit's ruling in Blum v. Commissioner. The Tenth Circuit affirmed a lower court finding that internet mogul Scott Blum cannot raise evidence that the IRS failed to countersign a key document.

Why it matters

The government's position that net earnings from self-employment is a partnership item, which must be determined at the partnership level rather than the partner level, could shape how similar disputes are handled. The filing signals the government is relying on the Tenth Circuit's reasoning in a separate federal appeal.

The dispute centers on a $16 million tax matter and a Tenth Circuit decision affirming that Blum cannot introduce evidence of an IRS countersignature failure. The source does not specify how the First Circuit will respond to the cited ruling.

The players

Scott Blum

Scott Blum is an internet mogul and the taxpayer at the center of the Blum v. Commissioner dispute.

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit

The Tenth Circuit is the federal appellate court that affirmed the lower court finding against Blum in this tax dispute.

The details

The Justice Department filed the notice of a recently published opinion from another circuit with the First Circuit on Tuesday. The filing points to the Tenth Circuit's affirmance in Blum v. Commissioner, which rejected Blum's attempt to raise evidence related to IRS countersignature.

Timeline

  1. Tuesday, November 10, 2026: Justice Department files notice with the First Circuit citing the Blum ruling.

Legal Precedent

The Justice Department's citation of Blum v. Commissioner in the First Circuit shows federal prosecutors using a Tenth Circuit affirmance to support the position that partnership-level determinations govern self-employment earnings. Whether other circuits adopt that reasoning will determine how broadly the ruling applies.

For taxpayers with self-employment income organized through partnerships, the government's position could affect whether certain earnings are reviewed at the partnership level or individually. The outcome may influence how similar IRS disputes are resolved in future cases.

The takeaway

Partnership-level tax treatment can significantly affect individual liability, so taxpayers in pass-through arrangements should review how their self-employment income is classified. Consulting a tax professional is advisable when disputes over IRS filings arise.

Further reading

For more background on federal tax disputes, explore the Taxes section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.