Nationwide Sues U.S. Over Providence Crash Payout

Insurer seeks $21,586.64 from the federal government after an ICE agent's government-owned SUV collided with a policyholder's BMW in Providence.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Crime

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a single red traffic signal above an empty urban intersection, set against a plain brick facade.
Nationwide Insurance and a Rhode Island policyholder have sued the United States, seeking $21,586.64 over a Providence crash involving an ICE agent's government SUV. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust the federal government to pay for crashes its employees cause?

Nationwide Insurance and policyholder Stacy Lacapra have sued the United States in federal court in Rhode Island over an October 14, 2025 collision in Providence. The three-page complaint alleges an ICE agent's government-owned Ford Expedition ran a red light without stopping or activating its siren before striking the BMW.

Why it matters

The suit seeks to recover insurance payouts from the federal government under a vicarious liability theory, testing how government vehicle crashes are compensated in Providence. It also raises questions about accountability when federal agents are involved in local traffic incidents.

The case is an active civil negligence action filed in U.S. District Court in Rhode Island, asserting a single count of negligence against the United States. Whether the government will contest liability or the damages amount has not been reported.

The players

Nationwide Insurance

Nationwide Insurance is a large American insurance company that provides auto and property coverage to millions of policyholders.

United States

The United States is the defendant in the suit, sued under a vicarious liability theory for the conduct of a federal vehicle operator.

The details

The complaint alleges that the Ford Expedition, owned by the Department of Homeland Security, struck a 2017 white BMW 330i owned by Stacy Lacapra while Mason Lacapra was driving it on Chalkstone Avenue and/or Oakland Avenue. The suit alleges the government vehicle traveled through a red light without stopping and did not activate its emergency siren.

Timeline

  1. October 14, 2025: Collision occurs in Providence between the government SUV and the BMW.

  2. November 18, 2026: Nationwide and Stacy Lacapra file the lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Rhode Island.

Legal Context

The suit relies on Rhode Island's vicarious liability statute, R.I.G.L. § 31-12-6, to pursue a federal defendant for a local negligence claim. Such suits test how state tort law applies when federal agents operate government vehicles on public roads.

Drivers in Providence sharing roads with government vehicles may have limited recourse if a crash occurs, depending on how the federal court resolves liability. Residents involved in similar collisions can expect insurers to pursue claims through the courts when the at-fault driver is a federal employee.

The takeaway

Government vehicle crashes can lead to lengthy federal litigation over who pays for damages. Anyone involved in such a collision should document the incident and track which insurer and agency are responsible.

Further reading

For more local crash coverage, see Providence Accidents.

Source note: This article includes information reported by GoLocalProv.

Live Poll

Do you trust the federal government to pay for crashes its employees cause?