Committee Weighs Matos Nomination to State Supreme Court

The House Judiciary Committee is scheduled to vote Tuesday on Judge Luis Matos's appointment amid allegations about his past abortion stance.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Law

Committee Weighs Matos Nomination to State Supreme Court

Live Poll

Should a judge's past personal views on abortion disqualify them from high court appointment?

The House Judiciary Committee is scheduled to vote on Governor's appointment of Superior Court Judge Luis Matos, a former federal prosecutor, to the Rhode Island Supreme Court. The vote follows emails from a Maryland woman alleging Matos urged her against an abortion in 1994, which Matos disputes, stating he is pro-choice.

Why it matters

The nomination raises questions for Rhode Island residents about how the state's highest court would interpret the state's abortion-rights law, passed in 2019, if a related case reaches it. Some lawmakers have voiced concern about appointing a once staunchly pro-life judge to a five-member court in the current legal climate after the U.S. Supreme Court's 6-to-3 ruling ended federal abortion protections.

The House Judiciary Committee is set to vote Tuesday, Nov. 17, on Governor's appointment of Judge Luis Matos to the five-member Rhode Island Supreme Court. Matos has denied a former partner's allegation that he urged her against an abortion in 1994, saying he has been pro-choice for many years.

The players

Luis Matos

A former federal prosecutor and current Rhode Island Superior Court judge whose nomination to the state Supreme Court is under committee review.

Christopher Blazejewski

The Speaker of the Rhode Island House of Representatives who declined to make written testimony on judicial nominees public.

Valarie Lawson

The President of the Rhode Island Senate who declined to make written testimony on judicial nominees public.

Alliance for Justice

A national advocacy organization with over 140 member groups that wrote in strong support of Matos's nomination.

The details

A Maryland woman sent emails to key lawmakers and abortion-rights advocacy groups describing Matos's stance as extreme pro-life and stating he impregnated her in 1994 and strongly urged her against an abortion while declining to raise the child. Matos issued a statement saying he is pro-choice; House Speaker Christopher Blazejewski and Senate President Valarie Lawson declined to make written testimony on judicial nominees public, with testimony taken in person under oath at the hearing.

Timeline

  1. 1994: Matos allegedly impregnated the Maryland woman.

  2. 2019: Rhode Island passed law enshrining abortion rights protections in state law.

  3. Tuesday, Nov. 17: House Judiciary Committee expected to vote on Matos's appointment.

Political Context

Opposition concerns center on whether a once staunchly pro-life judge can impartially interpret Rhode Island's 2019 abortion-rights law if a women's health case reaches the state Supreme Court. Some lawmakers have raised this concern in the context of the U.S. Supreme Court's 6-to-3 ruling that ended federal abortion protections after nearly 50 years.

The committee's decision determines whether Matos will sit on the five-member Supreme Court that could interpret Rhode Island's abortion-rights law. Residents concerned about how abortion cases are decided in state courts will see the outcome of this vote shape the court's composition.

The takeaway

The vote will show whether Rhode Island's Senate and House judiciary committees weigh a nominee's past personal views against his stated current position on abortion rights. Readers can track the committee's decision and the legal record that follows as the nomination moves forward.

What happens next

The House Judiciary Committee is expected to vote Tuesday, Nov. 17, on Matos's appointment to the Rhode Island Supreme Court.

Further reading

For more on the state's legal framework, see Law coverage of Rhode Island.

Source note: This article includes information reported by USA TODAY.

Live Poll

Should a judge's past personal views on abortion disqualify them from high court appointment?